What's wrong with this menu?
John's Pizza & Sub Shop
1436 Niagara Falls Blvd
Tonawanda, NY 14150
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Our Famous Subs
All Subs and Hoagies with Your Choice of a Costanzo Wheat, White or Sesame Seed Roll.
John's Original Chicken Finger Subs
Chicken Finger Sub
It's Now an Institution! Our Famous Chicken Fingers Shaken in our Tangy Hot Sauce with Lettuce, Tomato, Provolone Cheese, then Smothered with Kraft Blue Cheese.
- Small 8" Roll $8.09
- Large 12" $11.29
Stinger
A Mouthful of Juicy Rib Eye Steak & Tender Chicken Fingers, Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato, May we suggest Hot Sauce & Blue Cheese!
- Small 8" Roll $9.09
- Large 12" $14.49
The Western
Made with Plump Juicy Chicken Fingers, Smothered with our Delicious BBQ Sauce, Topped with American Cheese, Served on a Toasted Roll with Lettuce, Tomato & Mayo.
- Small 8" Roll $8.09
- Large 12" $11.29
The Chicken Club
Crispy Bacon tops our Golden Chicken Fingers with Lettuce, Tomato & Creamy Ranch Dressing.
- Small 8" Roll $8.39
- Large 12" $11.49
Specialty Subs
Steak-N-Ring
Our Delicious Steak with Lettuce & Tomato then Topped with Golden Brown Onion Rings & Smothered with Mozzarella Cheese.
- Small 8" Roll $8.09
- Whole 12" $11.29
The Nightmare
Rib Eye Steak, Italian Sausage, Lettuce, Tomato & Cheese, Double the meat with' Rib eye & Italian Sausage.
- Small 8" Roll $8.99
- Whole 12" $13.09
Steak in the Grass
Chopped Rib Eye Steak, Fresh Spinach Covered with Provolone Cheese Baked and then Topped with Lettuce & Tomato.
- Small 8" Roll $8.29
- Whole 12" $11.59
Chicken in the Grass
Grilled Chicken Tenderloin, Fresh Spinach Covered with Provolone Cheese Baked and then Topped with Lettuce & Tomato.
- Small 8" Roll $7.89
- Whole 12" $11.29
The Godfather
Thinly Sliced Ham & Capicola piled high, Baked with Pepperoni & Provolone Cheese then Topped with Lettuce & Tomato.
- Small 8" Roll $7.49
- Whole 12" $10.19
John's Hoagies
Steak Hoagie, Chicken Hoagie or Italian Sausage Hoagie. Sautéed Mushrooms, Onions and Your Choice of Hot, Banana or Green Peppers smothered in Mozzarella then Baked to Perfection.
- Small 8" Roll $7.89
- Whole 12" $11.29
Parmesan Subs
Meatball Parmesan
Plump Meatballs in our Spaghetti Sauce Covered with loads of Sorrento Provolone Cheese then Baked.
- Small 8" Roll $6.19
- Whole 12" $8.79
John's Italian Delight
Our version of a Sausage Parmesan in Our Original Sauce and Topped with Sorrento Provolone then Baked.
- Small 8" Roll $6.19
- Whole 12" $8.89
Chicken Parmesan Sub
Our Breaded Chicken Fingers with Spaghetti Sauce then Covered in Melted Sorrento Provolone Cheese.
- Small 8" Roll $6.89
- Whole 12" $9.79
Hot Subs
All Subs are Served on a toasted. Costanzo Roll with Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese & Oil or Kraft Mayonnaise. Any Sub can be Baked on Request!
Italian Sausage, Philly Chicken
- Half 6" $5.69
- Whole 12" $9.79
Ultimate Veggie Sub, Baked Cheese
- Half 6" $4.99
- Whole 12" $8.89
Pizza Sub, Fried Bologna & Onions
- Half 6" $4.99
- Whole 12" $8.79
Steak & Cheese, Royal, Fish Sub, Cheeseburger Sub
- Half 6" $6.19
- Whole 12" $10.59
Cold Subs
The Hercules
Over a third of a pound Thinly Sliced Ham & Turkey piled high on your choice of sub roll.
- Half 6" $6.19
- Whole 12" $10.29
Oven Roasted Turkey or Tuna Sub
- Half 6" $5.59
- Whole 12" $9.89
B.L.T Sub or Roast Beef
- Half 6" $6.19
- Whole 12" $11.19
Ham, Capicola, Salami or Assorted Sub
- Half 6" $5.49
- Whole 12" $9.29
Turkey Club Sub
- Half 6" $6.69
- Whole 12" $11.99
Pizza
Cheese Pizza
- Slice $2.55
- Small (6 Piece) $7.70
- Medium (8 Piece) $11.29
- Large (10 Piece) $16.04
- Half Tray (15 Piece) $16.04
- Party Tray (30 Piece) $26.59
- Gluten Free (6 Piece) $11.29
Additional Toppings
Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Extra Cheese, Mushrooms, Hot Peppers, Meatballs, Ham, Anchovies, Onion, Banana Peppers, Green Peppers, Pineapple, Diced Tomatoes, Black Olives, Green Olives, Bacon, Spinach
- Slice $0.45
- Small (6 Piece) $1.09
- Medium (8 Piece) $1.79
- Large (10 Piece) $2.95
- Half Tray (15 Piece) $2.95
- Party Tray (30 Piece) $4.59
- Gluten Free (6 Piece) $1.09
Gourmet Pizzas
The Original Chicken Finger Pizza
Tender Brakebush Chicken Fingers, Diced Celery and our Famous Chicken Finger Sauce, Covered with Sorrento Mozzarella.
- Small (6 Piece) $11.29
- Medium (8 Piece) $17.59
- Large (10 Piece) $24.59
- Half Tray (15 Piece) $24.59
- Party Tray (30 Piece) $42.49
- Gluten Free (6 Piece) $14.19
White Pizza
Our Fresh Pizza Crust topped with Shredded Romano, Parmesan, Sorrento Mozzarella cheeses and a Hint of Fresh Garlic & Olive Oil then topped with Onions and Diced Tomatoes.
- Small (6 Piece) $11.29
- Medium (8 Piece) $17.59
- Large (10 Piece) $24.59
- Half Tray (15 Piece) $24.59
- Party Tray (30 Piece) $42.49
- Gluten Free (6 Piece) $14.19
Spinach & Tomato Pizza
Our Pizza Crust topped with Garlic & Olive Oil then Fresh Spinach covered with Romano, Parmesan & Mozzarella Cheese and topped with Sliced Tomato.
- Small (6 Piece) $11.29
- Medium (8 Piece) $17.59
- Large (10 Piece) $24.59
- Half Tray (15 Piece) $24.59
- Party Tray (30 Piece) $42.49
- Gluten Free (6 Piece) $14.19
3 Cheese Steak Pizza
Our Fresh Pizza Dough Topped with Grilled Rib Eye Steak, Fresh Mushrooms, Chopped Onions Over a Layer of Garlic Butter, then Smothered in Sorrento Mozzarella, Swiss & American Cheeses served with your choice of Hot, Banana or Green Peppers.
- Small (6 Piece) $11.29
- Medium (8 Piece) $17.59
- Large (10 Piece) $24.59
- Half Tray (15 Piece) $24.59
- Party Tray (30 Piece) $42.49
- Gluten Free (6 Piece) $14.19
Meat Eaters Supreme
Our Cheese Pizza Topped with Pepperoni, Meatballs, Bacon and Ham.
- Small (6 Piece) $11.29
- Medium (8 Piece) $17.59
- Large (10 Piece) $24.59
- Half Tray (15 Piece) $24.59
- Party Tray (30 Piece) $42.49
- Gluten Free (6 Piece) $14.19
John's House Combo
Our Customer's Favorite; Pepperoni, Sausage, Onion & Green Pepper over Sorrento Mozzarella with our Traditional Pizza Sauce.
- Small (6 Piece) $11.29
- Medium (8 Piece) $17.59
- Large (10 Piece) $24.59
- Half Tray (15 Piece) $24.59
- Party Tray (30 Piece) $42.49
- Gluten Free (6 Piece) $14.19
John's Big Mac
Crumbled Hamburger, Thousand Island Dressing, Our Three Cheese Blend with Chopped Pickles & Onions, then Topped with Lettuce on our Sesame Seeded fresh Pizza Dough!
- Small (6 Piece) $11.29
- Medium (8 Piece) $17.59
- Large (10 Piece) $24.59
- Half Tray (15 Piece) $24.59
- Party Tray (30 Piece) $42.49
- Gluten Free (6 Piece) $14.19
Taco Pizza
Our fresh baked pizza crust topped with Salsa, Our own Fresh Taco Meat, Cheddar Cheese, Black Olives and baked to perfection, topped with Lettuce & Tomato!
- Small (6 Piece) $11.29
- Medium (8 Piece) $17.59
- Large (10 Piece) $24.59
- Half Tray (15 Piece) $24.59
- Party Tray (30 Piece) $42.49
- Gluten Free (6 Piece) $14.19
Rodeo Burger Pizza
A blend of our Barbecue & Garlic Sauces, Grilled Burger, Onion Rings with American & Mozzarella Cheese.
- Small (6 Piece) $11.29
- Medium (8 Piece) $17.59
- Large (10 Piece) $24.59
- Half Tray (15 Piece) $24.59
- Party Tray (30 Piece) $42.49
- Gluten Free (6 Piece) $14.19
Stinger Pizza
Our Pizza Crust smothered in Kraft Blue Cheese with Tender Chunks of Rib Eye Steak & Tyson Chicken Fingers tossed in Hot Sauce then covered with Mozzarella & Provolone Cheese.
- Small $12.49
- Medium $19.49
- Large or Half Tray $26.19
- Party Tray $43.39
Wings
Served with Celery, Carrots & Blue Cheese. Hot, Medium, Mild, Barbecue, Cajun or Garlic Parmesan. Choose from Our Famous Chicken Wings or Our New Boneless Wings.
Chicken Wings & Boneless Wings
- Single (10) $11.49
- Double (20) $19.49
- Triple (30) $27.89
- Bucket (50) $40.49
- Extra Blue Cheese Dressing
- $0.95
- Extra Carrots & Celery
- $0.89
Chicken Fingers
- Individual Finger (ea) $2.09
- Single (5 Fingers with Fries) $11.39
- Double (10 Fingers with Fries) $19.19
- 20 Tyson Fingers $29.99
- 30 Tyson Fingers $44.79
- Extra Blue Cheese
- $0.95
- Extra Celery & Carrots
- $0.89
Salads
Served with a Side of kraft Dressings. Extra Dressing $0.79 each.
Chef Salad
- Small $3.59
- Large $7.19
- Party Size (Minimum 10 Person ) (per person) $1.75
Antipasto
A Mixture of Peppers, Cheese, Cold Cuts, Olives, Onions & Fresh Salad Green. It's a Meal in Itself!
- Small $6.19
- Large $10.59
- Party Size (Minimum 10 Person ) (per person) $3.19
Julienne Salad
A Fresh Bed of Salad Greens & Tomatoes, Topped with Turkey, Ham, Shredded Cheddar Cheese, Garnished with Cucumber and Hard Boiled Eggs.
- Small $4.89
- Large $8.59
- Party Size (Minimum 10 Person) (per person) $2.59
Apple Almond Grilled Chicken Salad
A Fresh Blend of Salad Greens, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Diced Apple, Craisins, Feta Cheese and Slivered Almond covered with Tender Strips of Char-Broiled Chicken Breast Tenderloin.
- Small $5.09
- Large $9.29
- Party Size (Minimum 10 Person) (per person) $3.19
Beef Taco Salad
$8.99
A Crispy Tortilla Shell filled with Shredded Lettuce, Diced Tomato, Shredded Cheddar Cheese, Black Olives, Hot Peppers and served with Salsa & Sour Cream on the side.
Chicken Taco Salad
$9.09
A Crispy Tortilla Shell filled with Shredded Lettuce, Diced Tomato, Shredded Cheddar Cheese, Black Olives, Hot Peppers and served with Salsa & Sour Cream on the side.
Greek Salad
Fresh Salad Greens with Chicken or Steak Topped with Green & Black Olives, Feta Cheese, Sweet Peppers, Hard Boiled Egg, Cucumber & Tomatoes, served with Greek Dressing on the side.
- Small $5.99
- Large $10.29
- Party Size (Minimum 10 Person) (per person) $3.19
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Fresh Salad Greens, Cheddar Cheese, Tomatoes, Cucumbers & Hard Boiled Egg topped with Tender Chicken Fingers tossed in Hot Sauce. We recommend our Kraft Blue Cheese Dressing.
- Small $5.09
- Large $9.89
- Party Size (Minimum 10 Person) (per person) $3.45
Tacos & Wraps
Made with a Fresh White or Wheat Tortilla Shell. Served Hot, Medium or Mild. Add Sour Cream $0.65.
Beef Taco
$5.79
Fresh Ground Beef Grilled with a Mexican flare over Cheese, Shredded Lettuce and Tomato.
Buffalo Wrap
$7.09
Brakebush Chicken Fingers Shaken in our Hot Sauce, with Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato and Kraft Blue Cheese.
Grilled Chicken Wrap
$5.79
Grilled Chicken Tenderloin with Cheese, Lettuce, and Tomato.
Stinger Wrap
$9.19
Grilled Rib-Eye Steak, Diced Chicken Fingers, Lettuce, Tomato & Cheese Smothered in Kraft Blue Cheese.
Greek Wrap
$7.09
Choose from Grilled Chicken Tenderloin or Rib Eye Steak with Lettuce, Tomato, Feta Cheese, Banana Peppers, Black Olives & Greek Dressing.
Fish Taco
$5.99
Breaded Cod Filet on your choice of tortilla with American Cheese, Tartar, Lettuce & Tomato.
A La Carte
Hot Poppers (9)
$6.89Onion Rings
$4.29Pizza Logs (4)
$7.29BBQ Pizza Logs (4)
$7.69French Fries
$2.89Seasoned Curly Q's
$3.09Chips
$1.45Soup of the Day
$3.98Mozzarella Sticks (5)
$6.29Cheesy Garlic Sticks
Served with a side of Marinara.
- Small $2.89
- Large $4.89
Buffalo Bread
$8.39
Our Garlic Bread Topped with Diced Chicken Fingers Tossed in Hot Sauce with Blue Cheese and Melted Mozzarella.
Fried Pickle Chips
$5.89
With Ranch Dressing.
Sample Platter
$14.69
Your Pick 4 for Pizza Logs (3), Mozzarella Sticks (3), Hot Poppers (5), Small Cheesy Bread Sticks, Chicken Fingers (3), Onion Rings (5), French Fries.
Something Different
Fish Fry (Available Daily)
$13.99
Beer Battered Icelandic Haddock with Cole Slaw, French Fries & Garlic Bread.
Beef on Weck
$8.29
Over a Quarter Pound of Thinly Sliced Prime Beef dipped in Au Jus served on a Toasted Kimmelweck or Plan roll with Fries, Horseradish & Pickles.
Beverages
Beverages
- Medium $2.19
- Large $2.69
- 20 oz Bottle $2.45
- 2 Liter Bottle $2.99
Bottled Water
$1.85Coffee
$1.79Desserts
Apple Granny Logs with Glazed Dipping Sauce
$5.89Fresh Baked Chocolate Chip Cookies
$1.45American Classic Ice Cream Truffles
$4.25
Choose from: Cookies & Cream, Peanut Butter & Vanilla, Birthday Cake & more.
Sub Platter
5 Subs cut in 1/4's on White, Wheat or Sesame. Arranged on Serving Tray with sides of Mayo, Oil, Hot & Banana Peppers.
Cold Cut Patter
$48.79
Roast Beef, Ham, Turkey, Assorted, Hercules (Ham & Turkey).
John's Original Sub Platter
$48.79
3 Oven Roasted Turkey, 2 Ham & Cheese.
Chicken Finger Sub Platter
$55.69
5 Famous Chicken Finger Subs made to your liking.
Wrap Platter
10 of Our Delicious Wraps Cut in Halves and Arranged on a Domed Platter Condiment Sides available upon request.
Assorted Wrap Platter
$56.69
3 Turkey Wraps, 3 Ham & Cheese Wraps, 2 Greek Wraps w/ Chicken, 2 Grilled Chicken Wraps.
Buffalo Wrap Platter
$58.79
6 Original Buffalo Chicken Wraps with Hot Sauce, Blue Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese, 4 Western Wraps with Barbecue Sauce, Mayo, Lettuce, Tomato & American Cheese.
Daily Lunch Specials
Two Slices of Cheese & Pepperoni or Our Gourmet Pizza Slices & a Medium Beverage
$6.09Sub of the Week
- Half $4.95
- Whole $8.49
Small Sub of the Week
$8.19
with Your Choice of Fries, Chips, Chef Salad or Soup and a Medium Beverage (add $0.59).
Buffalo's Best Beef on Week
$8.29
with Fries and a Medium Beverage.
Buy Any Half Sub
$3.89
Add Your Choice of Fries, Chips, Chef Salad or Soup ($0.59) and a medium Beverage for an Additional.
Pizza Combo Deals
Medium Cheese & One Item Pizza
$20.89
With 10 Wings or 10 Boneless Wings or 7 Chicken Fingers.
Medium Gourmet Pizza
$25.29
With 10 Wings or 10 Boneless Wings or 7 Chicken Fingers.
Large or Half Tray Cheese & One Item Pizza
$34.19
With 20 Wings or 20 Boneless Wings or 12 Fingers.
Large or Half Tray Gourmet Pizza
$37.99
With 20 wings or 20 boneless wings or 12 fingers.
Party Tray Cheese & One Item Pizza
$52.99
With 30 Wings or 30 Boneless Wings or 20 Chicken Fingers.
Party Tray Gourmet Pizza
$60.99
With 30 Wings or 30 Boneless Wings or 20 Chicken Fingers.
Party Tray Cheese & One Item Pizza
$62.89
With 50 Wings or 50 Boneless Wings or 30 Chicken Fingers.
Party Tray Gourmet Pizza
$68.59
With 50 Wings or 50 Boneless Wings or 30 Chicken Fingers.
Browse Nearby
General Info
Payment Types
All Major Cards
Cuisine
Pizza
Meals
Lunch
Dinner
Hours
Monday:
10:30am - 10:30pm
Tuesday:
10:30am - 10:30pm
Wednesday:
10:30am - 10:30pm
Thursday:
10:30am - 10:30pm
Friday:
10:00am - 12:00am
Saturday:
11:00am - 12:00am
Sunday:
11:00am - 10:30pm
About Us
Home of the Origanal Chicken Finger Sub serving WNY since 1982!
We serve quality food with great friendly service at great prices. Your one stop pizza shop with outsanding pizza, subs and wings!