What's wrong with this menu?
Ivy Bakery
40 Madison Street
New York, NY 10038
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
more menus
Main Menu
Catering
Main Menu
Muffins
Light, fluffy, and just slightly sweet. Perfect for breakfast, brunch, or a quick snack. Enjoy with your favorite tea or coffee
Wild Blueberry
seasonal berries, sweet and tart, topped with cinnamon-sugar
- Dz $33.00
Almond Pistachio
crushed pistachios, topped with slivered almonds and icing
- Dz $34.00
Cinnamon Streusel
spicy cinnamon, topped with brown sugar and oat streusel
- Dz $32.00
Chocolate Chip
vanilla, generous chocolate chips, topped with a sprinkle of sugar
- Dz $32.00
Classic Corn
stone ground cornmeal, crumbly, topped with a sprinkle of sugar
- Dz $32.00
Pumpkin Spice
pureed pumpkin, assorted spices, topped with cinnamon-sugar
- Dz $32.00
Apple Cranberry
diced seasonal apples, dried cranberries (fresh, when in season), topped with cinnamon-sugar
- Dz $32.00
Lemon Yogurt Poppy Seed
lemon zest, juice, yogurt, seeds, topped with lemon icing
- Dz $32.00
Strawberry Chocolate Chip
diced strawberries, generous chocolate chips, nutmeg, topped with cinnamon-sugar
- Dz $32.00
Honey Oat Pecan
bran, steel cut oats, local honey, topped with pecan cinnamon streusel
- Dz $34.00
Apple Spice
diced apples, assorted spices, topped with cinnamon-sugar
- Dz $32.00
Chocolate Espresso Cacao Nib
cocoa, espresso, cacao nibs, topped with ganache
- Dz $34.00
Carrot Walnut
hand shredded carrots, assorted spices, toasted walnut, topped with cinnamon-sugar
- Dz $32.00
Banana Peanut Butter
ripe bananas, creamy peanut butter, topped with cinnamon-sugar
- Dz $32.00
Coconut Milk
shredded coconut, condensed milk, topped with toasted coconut
- Dz $34.00
Scones
Buttery and crispy, but still tender on the inside. Serve toasted with your favorite jam, clotted cream, or as is
Plain
Buttermilk, topped with a sprinkle of sugar
- Dz $30.00
Wild Blueberry
sweet and tart berries, topped with cinnamon-sugar
- Dz $32.00
Cherry Almond
dried cherries, topped with slivered almonds and icing
- Dz $32.00
Cinnamon Raisin Walnut
spicy cinnamon, raisins, toasted walnuts, topped with cinnamon-sugar
- Dz $32.00
Orange Cranberry
orange zest, dried cranberries (fresh when in season), topped with icing
- Dz $32.00
Cheddar Scones
shredded sharp cheddar
- Dz $32.00
Coffee Cake
Not made with coffee, but perfect with a cup of coffee. Tender and light buttermilk cake topped with streusel
Caramel Apple Spice
diced apples, cinnamon, nutmeg, topped with homemade caramel
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Banana Chocolate Chip
ripe bananas and generous chocolate chips
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Cinnamon Streusel
cinnamon brown sugar layer, crunchy streusel
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Pumpkin Cranberry
pureed pumpkin, assorted spices, dried cranberries (fresh when in season)
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Wile Blueberry-lemon
seasonal berries, lemon zest
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Ricotta-almond
whole milk ricotta, slivered almonds and icing
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Apricot-oat
apricot preserves, dried apricots, spices, and oat streusel
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Espresso Walnut
ground espresso, chopped walnuts, and vanilla streusel
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Chocolate Cinnamon
cocoa, cinnamon, and chocolate streusel
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Sweet Breads
Banana
$26.00
just bananas, lots of ripe bananas, touch of cinnamon
Carrot Walnut
$26.00
hand shredded carrots, assorted spices, and toasted walnuts
Pumpkin Pecan
$26.00
pureed pumpkin, spices, and toasted pecans
Maple Coconut
$26.00
pure maple syrup, shredded coconut, nutmeg
Cinnamon Rum Raisin
$28.00
spicy cinnamon and rum soaked raisins
Gingerbread
$26.00
blackstrap mollases, assorted spices, fresh finger
Pastries
Puffy, fluffy, crispy, buttery, and all those other delicious good things
Palmiers
french style puff pastry sugar cookies
- Dz $30.00
Profiteroles Aka Cream Puffs
light, airy, filled with your choice of custard or homemade cream
- Dz $45.00
Eclairs
light, airy, tube shaped cream puffs filled with your choice of custard or homemade cream, topped with ganache
- Dz $45.00
Novelty Cakes / Baked Goods
Baked goodies and delicious classic cakes made with special pans and techniques. Cakes are approximately 9". Pound cakes come in a loaf or Bundt
Old Fashion Gingerbread
$42.00
baked in a tray and cut into squares, blackstrap molasses, spices, and fresh ginger
Angel Food (Vanilla or Chocolate)
$42.00
baked in a tube pan, and made of egg whites, cake flour, and a touch of sugar, cooled upside down to keep its shape
Pineapple Upside Down
$42.00
homemade brown sugar syrup, pineapples, maraschino cherries, and vanilla cake batter. baked and flipped upside down before serving
Pound Cake (Vanilla or Lemon)
$42.00
a pound of everything and extra love. baked in your choice of a loaf or bundt pan
Bundt Cake (Ginger, Pumpkin, or Rum)
baked in a bundt pan and released upside down. try the rum, soaked in simple sugar and a bottle of rum
- $42.00
- $52.00
Flourless Chocolate Cake
$42.00
dense, fudgy, and melt in your mouth chocolate heaven
Cola Cake
our favorite cola soda and marshmallows baked into a chocolate cake, frosted with cola icing and chopped pecans
- Tray 9x13 $42.00
Irish Soda Bread
made in individual loaves, caraway seeds, raisins, currants, or plain if you'd like
- Loaves 6 $24.00
Baked Doughnuts
mini cinnamon spiced baked doughnuts with vanilla glaze or chocolate and nonpareils
- Pieces 24 $36.00
Bread Pudding
assorted breads, croissants, soaked in vanilla custard and baked with sweet or savory additions. think ham and swiss or maple apple. you decide, contact us for more info
- Tray 9x13 $48.00
Homemade Granola
mixed nuts, seeds, oats, spices, dried fruit, and olive oil with a touch of honey. let us customize it with your favorite mix-ins
- (per lb) $11.00
Butter Gooeys
Our famous butter gooeys in an assortment of flavors. What's a butter gooey? Half cake, half cheesecake, and a whole lot of amazing. They originally come from St. Louis, Missouri. I was given a recipe almost a decade ago during my time down south which called for boxed cake mix. That being a no no, I rewrote it with my own cake recipe and tadaa! the best thing you'll ever put in your mouth! The classic is a must try, then cinnamon, coconut, chocolate, oh just try them all!
Classic Vanilla
vanilla crust and custard
- Tray 9x13 $52.00
Double Chocolate
cocoa crust, cocoa custard
- Tray 9x13 $52.00
Cinnamon
spiced crust, ground cinnamon custard
- Tray 9x13 $52.00
Coconut
shredded coconut crust, coconut milk custard
- Tray 9x13 $52.00
Red Velvet
cocoa crust, red velvet custard
- Tray 9x13 $52.00
Almond Pistachio
pistachio crust, almond custard
- Tray 9x13 $52.00
Espresso
vanilla crust, espresso infused custard
- Tray 9x13 $52.00
Peanut Butter
peanut butter crust, peanut butter custard
- Tray 9x13 $52.00
Apple Caramel
spiced crust, diced apple custard, homemade caramel
- Tray 9x13 $52.00
Banana
vanilla crust, banana custard
- Tray 9x13 $52.00
Chocolate Hazelnut
hazelnut crust, chocolate custard
- Tray 9x13 $52.00
Pumpkin Spice
spiced crust, pureed pumpkin custard
- Tray 9x13 $52.00
Truffles
Creamy, melt-in-your-mouth, hand rolled truffles. Keep chilled and extras on hand, they disappear fast!
Strawberry Cheesecake
rich ganache blended with chunks of cream cheese and strawberry preserves, rolled in crushed graham crackers
- Dz $24.00
Bittersweet Chocolate
for the straight up chocolate lover, rich ganache rolled in unsweetened cacao
- Dz $24.00
Cherry Almond
rich ganache blended with dried cherries and pure almond oil, rolled in chopped almonds
- Dz $24.00
Espresso
rich ganache blended with fresh ground espresso beans, rolled in more ground beans
- Dz $24.00
Ginger Coconut
rich ganache blended with freshly grated ginger, rolled in toasted coconut
- Dz $24.00
Raspberry Green Tea
rich ganache blended with raspberry preserves, rolled in matcha
- Dz $24.00
Peanut Butter Crunch
rich ganache blended with creamy peanut butter, rolled in chopped peanuts
- Dz $24.00
Peppermint
rich ganache blended with peppermint oil, rolled in unsweetened cacao
- Dz $24.00
Mexican & Cayenne
rich ganache blended with cinnamon and hot cayenne, rolled in unsweetened cacao
- Dz $24.00
Cobblers
Baked fruit covered in a crisp muffin-top crust with cinnamon sugar. It's always best to order seasonal fruit for the tastiest cobbler
Wild Blueberry
fresh wild blueberries when in season, cinnamon, butter crust
- Tray 8x8 $38.00
Peach
fresh peaches, nutmeg, butter crust
- Tray 8x8 $38.00
Strawberry
fresh strawberries, nutmeg, butter crust
- Tray 8x8 $38.00
Apple
mixed apples, cinnamon, nutmeg, butter crust
- Tray 8x8 $38.00
Sweet Cherry
cherries, nutmeg, almond extract, butter crust
- Tray 8x8 $38.00
Triple Berry
blueberries, blackberries, strawberries when in season, cinnamon, nutmeg, butter crust
- Tray 8x8 $38.00
Bars
A square or rectangle never tasted so good!
Apple Cinnamon
fresh mixed apples baked with cinnamon, soft, cake-like
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Almond Oat (Raspberry, Apricot, or Strawberry)
crumbly almond oat bars filled with your choice of fruit preserve
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Lemon
homemade lemon curd bars with shortbread bottoms
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Marshmallow Rice
nostalgic favorite of puffed rice blended with marshmallows, sticky and chewy
- Tray 9x13 $28.00
Pumpkin Pecan
brown sugar, pumpkin, spices, pecan shortbread bottom
- Tray 8x8 $28.00
Brownies
Fudgy chocolate cake bars baked with your favorite mix-ins
Chocolate Chip
classic fudge brownies with chocolate chips
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Banana Caramel
ripe mashed bananas, fudge brownie, homemade caramel
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Marbled Cream Cheese
fudge brownie swirled with sweet cream cheese batter
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Cherry White Chip
fudge brownie, chopped sweet cherries, white chocolate chips
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Chocolate Truffle
fudge brownie topped with walnuts (optional) and a thick layer of ganache
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Cookies N' Cream
fudge brownie batter blended with chopped sandwich cookies
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Raspberry Walnut
fudge brownie, raspberry preserves, chopped walnuts
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Nutella
fudge brownie batter swirled with nutella (chocolate-hazelnut)
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Blondies
Fudgy brown sugar cake bars baked with your favorite mix-ins
Chocolate Chip
brown sugar, butter, chocolate chips
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Espresso Walnut
fresh ground espresso beans, brown sugar, chopped walnuts
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Cinnamon Coconut
brown sugar, butter, cinnamon, shredded coconut
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Peanut Butter Chocolate
brown sugar, butter, peanut butter, chocolate chips
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Banana Peanut Butter
mashed ripe bananas, cinnamon, peanut butter
- Tray 8x8f $32.00
Butterscotch
brown sugar, butter, x2
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Maple Pecan
real maple syrup, chopped pecans
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
White Chip Macadamia
brown sugar, butter, white chocolate chips, macadamia nuts
- Tray 8x8 $32.00
Confections
Dipped fruit, candies, and small bite-size homemade confections
Chocolate Covered Strawberries
fresh strawberries dipped in your choice of milk, dark, or white chocolate, ask us about long stem strawberries when in season
- Pieces 24 $32.00
Irish Potato Candy
cream cheese, coconut, rolled in cinnamon, truly divine, a must-try
- Pieces 24 $36.00
Chocolate Covered Pretzel Rods
crunchy salty pretzel rods dipped in chocolate and covered in sprinkles or candies
- Pieces 24 $36.00
Buckeyes (PB Chocolate Balls)
an Ohio classic, peanut butter balls dipped in chocolate
- Pieces 24 $36.00
Marshmallows
homemade marshmallows made with sugar, gelatin, and vanilla
- Pieces 24 $36.00
Savory
Our savory store favorites now available for order in full sizes for your next meal. Par-baked and ready to heat and serve
Chicken Pot Pie
all white meat chicken, celery, green onions, white sauce, cheddar, flaky pastry
- Tray 8x8 $42.00
Veggie Pot Pie
sautéed seasonal veggies, white sauce, cheddar, flaky pastry
- Tray 8x8 $42.00
Shepherd's Pie
fresh ground chuck, onions, carrots, peas, mashed potatoes, provolone
- Tray 8x8 $42.00
Mac N' Cheese
gluten free macaroni, cream sauce, sharp cheddar, romano, provolone
- Tray 8x8 $42.00
Tres Leches
One of our most popular shop desserts, first sold in cups, can be ordered by they tray for your next event. Wait, what is it? Three milk cake, our vanilla cake recipe soaked with whole milk, condensed milk, and evaporated milk, topped with fresh whipped cream. You'll want a bowl and spoon for this one
Vanilla
light vanilla cake, three milks, fresh cream
- Tray 9x13 $42.00
Fresh Strawberry
with the addition of fresh sliced strawberries
- Tray 9x13 $42.00
Chocolate
chocolate cake, three milks, fresh cream
- Tray 9x13 $42.00
Cinnamon
vanilla cake baked with cinnamon, three milks, fresh cream
- Tray 9x13 $42.00
Coconut
coconut cake, shredded coconut, three milks, fresh cream
- Tray 9x13 $42.00
Pumpkin
pumpkin cake, spices, three milks, fresh cream
- Tray 9x13 $42.00
Cakes / Cupcakes / Cake Pops
Frosted layered cakes (pricing below), cupcakes - mini ($48) or standard ($38), cake balls ($32) or pops ($45). Sold by the dozen / mini cupcakes 4 dozen. Contact us for custom designs or flavor creations. We use buttercream frosting for all our hand drawn designs which means a tasty cake from top to bottom. We do not use fondant
Apple Spice
fresh seasonal apples, cinnamon, cream cheese frosting
- 9" $42.00
- 12" or 9x13 $85.00
Banana Coconut
fresh ripe bananas, toasted coconut, cream cheese frosting
- 9" $42.00
- 12" or 9x13 $85.00
Black Forest
chocolate cake, kirsch liquor, cherries, buttercream, whipped cream
- 9" $42.00
- 12" or 9x13 $85.00
Boston Cream
vanilla cake, vanilla custard, chocolate ganache
- 9" $42.00
- 12" or 9x13 $85.00
Carrot
grated carrots, crushed pineapples, raisins and walnuts (optional), cream cheese frosting
- 9" $42.00
- 12" or 9x13 $85.00
Chocolate Peanut Butter
chocolate cake, peanut butter buttercream
- 9" $42.00
- 12" or 9x13 $85.00
Lemon Coconut
lemon cake, toasted coconut, vanilla buttercream
- 9" $42.00
- 12" or 9x13 $85.00
Devil's Food
moist chocolate cake, chocolate buttercream
- 9" $42.00
- 12" or 9x13 $85.00
German Chocolate
chocolate cake, coconut pecan custard, chocolate ganache
- 9" $42.00
- 12" or 9x13 $85.00
Irish Potato
vanilla cake, cream cheese frosting, toasted coconut, cinnamon
- 9" $42.00
- 12" or 9x13 $85.00
Pumpkin Spice
pumpkin, cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves, ginger, cream cheese frosting
- 9" $42.00
- 12" or 9x13 $85.00
Red Velvet
buttermilk cocoa cake, cream cheese frosting
- 9" $42.00
- 12" or 9x13 $85.00
Blue Velvet
buttermilk cocoa cake, cinnamon, cream cheese frosting
- 9" $42.00
- 12" or 9x13 $85.00
S'mores
graham cake, chocolate ganache, toasted marshmallows
- 9" $42.00
- 12" or 9x13 $85.00
Mocha
cocoa, ground espresso beans, chocolate ganache
- 9" $42.00
- 12" or 9x13 $85.00
Strawberry Shortcake
vanilla cake, fresh sliced strawberries, whipped cream
- 9" $42.00
- 12" or 9x13 $85.00
Cookies
Drop cookies, rolled cookies, filled cookies, decorated cookies, get 'em all here! Sold by the dozen
Chocolate Chip
$28.00
vanilla cookie with shaved chocolate and chocolate chips
Oatmeal (Raisin, Choc Chip, or Butterscotch)
$28.00
spiced oatmeal cookies with your choice of fix-ins
Flourless Peanut Butter
$28.00
melt in your mouth, just natural peanut butter, sugar, and eggs
Maple Walnut White Chip
$28.00
real maple syrup, butter cookie, white chips
Peanut Butter Banana
$28.00
natural peanut butter, fresh ripe bananas, cinnamon
Chinese Almond
$28.00
ground almonds, crispy egg glaze
Snickerdoodles
$28.00
old fashion cinnamon sugar cookies
Texas Ranger
$28.00
oats, coconut, and corn flakes, yes really, and it's amazing!
Cookies N' Cream
$28.00
chocolate sandwich cookie chunks in a cookie
Chocolate Crinkles
$28.00
chewy chocolate cookies with crackled confectioners' sugar
Rainbow Confetti
$28.00
super fun vanilla butter cookies studded with rainbow sprinkles
Double Chocolate
$28.00
cocoa cookie base loaded with chocolate chips
Ginger Chocolate Chip
$28.00
fresh ginger, molasses, spices, chocolate chips
Green Tea Pistachio
$28.00
japanese matcha, chopped pistachios
Raspberry Linzer
$28.00
cutout pecan sandwich cookies filled with raspberry preserves, topped with confectioners' sugar
Butter Shortbread
$28.00
crispy buttery cookies perfect with afternoon tea
Classic Sugar
order them as basic drop cookies topped with sugar crystals or get them decorated for the holidays, special occasions, or your logo with royal icing, contact us for a price quote
- $28.00
- (each) $4.75
Rugelach
$28.00
Light and flaky cream cheese pastry filled with cinnamon sugar, your favorite fruit preserves, or chocolate chips
Pies
9" from scratch pies with flaky pastry or graham crust. Seasonal fruit pies are divine, but make sure you try our best seller for the past 10 years, Buttermilk Pie!
Buttermilk
$36.00
our most popular pie and the bakers personal favorite. a sweet cross between creme brûlée and egg custard
Almond
$36.00
ground almonds, almond extract, sweet custard with a crunch
Chocolate
$36.00
unsweetened cocoa blended with buttermilk and eggs, rich and creamy
Peanut Butter
$36.00
for the pb lover, thick, dense, creamy, what more could you ask for
Banoffee
$36.00
an english pie made with fresh bananas, cream, toffee, and crumbled biscuits
Coconut
$36.00
classic sweet coconut custard made with shredded coconut and milk
Butterscotch
$36.00
buttery brown sugar custard
Banana
$36.00
mashed ripe bananas and a touch of cinnamon
Cinnamon
$36.00
sweet custard generously blended with cinnamon creating a light crispy top
Espresso
$36.00
freshly ground espresso beans baked in
Green Tea
$36.00
japanese matcha and egg custard
Lemon
$36.00
sweet and tart lemon custard with extra zest
Nutella
$36.00
chocolate and hazelnut spread
Pumpkin Spice
$36.00
pumpkin puree baked with cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves, ginger, and allspice
Shoo Fly
$36.00
some say it's an acquired taste, made with lots of molasses, this is a sticky one
Classic Apple
$38.00
your basic piled high apple pie baked with cinnamon, brown sugar, and butter
Dutch Apple
$36.00
cinnamon spiced apples baked with a vanilla butter streusel topping
Chocolate Chip
$36.00
is it a cookie or a pie?
Sweet Cherry
cherries, nutmeg, and a touch of pure almond extract
- $36.00
- $38.00
Wild Blueberry
rich, sweet, and full of blueberries, topped with a spiced oat streusel
- $36.00
- $38.00
Blackberry Blueberry
seasonal blackberries and blueberries with a touch of spice
- $36.00
- $38.00
Peach
filled with peaches, brown sugar, and a bit of butter and spice
- $36.00
- $38.00
Key Lime
$36.00
These tiny limes pack a tart kick and make the ultimate lime pie
Lemon Meringue
$36.00
lemon custard topped with fresh toasted meringue
Lemonade Ice Box
$36.00
a no-bake lemon custard pie with a cinnamon graham cracker crust
Banana Cream
$36.00
flaky pastry, homemade vanilla pudding, fresh sliced bananas, made from scratch whipped cream
Chocolate Cream
$36.00
flaky pastry, homemade chocolate pudding, made from scratch whipped cream
Strawberry Cream
$36.00
it's like strawberry ice cream, but in a pie!
Coconut Cream
$36.00
flaky pastry, homemade coconut pudding, made from scratch whipped cream, toasted coconut
Peaches N' Cream
$36.00
fresh peach compote with a pinch of nutmeg, topped with made from scratch whipped cream
Pecan
$36.00
brown sugar, butter, and lots of pecans
Chocolate Pecan
$36.00
same great pecan pie but with added cocoa
Maple Walnut
$36.00
maple sweetened custard studded with toasted walnuts
Strawberry Rhubarb
fresh strawberries and seasonal rhubarb, that perfect sweet and tart combo
- $36.00
- $38.00
Maple Bacon Pecan
$36.00
yes, that's right, real maple syrup, baked bacon, and toasted pecans, what are you waiting for?
Main
For servings of 70 and up - please contact us for special pricing on large orders
Random Assortment of Regular sized Cookies, Bars, Brownies, & Cupcakes
Appropriate for groups of 12 or less
- 2-4 Servings $45.00
- 5-8 Servings $85.00
- 9-12 Servings $165.00
Random Assortment of Miniature sized Cookies, Bars, Brownies, & Cupcakes
Appropriate for groups of 10 or more
- 10-20 Servings $95.00
- 30-40 Servings $175.00
- 50-60 Servings $255.00