What's wrong with this menu?
Heavenly Creamery
264 Sandusky St
Conneaut, US-OH 44030
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Conneaut's only small batch premium custard parlor. Serving over 150 custom flavored custard and sorbets thoughout the season
Main
Water
$1.00Coffee / Tea
$1.85Frozen Lemonade / Sweet Tea
- Sm $2.75
- Lg $4.25
Hard Serve Milk Shake
- 1/2 Pound $7.00
- 1 Pound $10.75
Texas Sheetcake
$3.50Bubble Tea
$4.50
Sweet or Unsweet tea with Boba
Frozen Lemonade / Sweet tea with Boba
$6.00Can Pop
$1.25Soft serve Milkshake
- 1/2 pound $4.50
- 1 Pound $6.50
Ice-Creams
Cones: Cake, Sugar, Waffle +$0.80
Junior Cone
- Hard $2.75
- Soft Serve $2.00
Small Cone
- Hard $4.00
- Soft Serve $2.75
95Regular Cone
- Hard $5.45
- Soft Serve $3.35
Large Cone
- Hard $7.50
- Soft Serve $4.00
Choc Dip Cone
$1.60Choc + Topping Cone
$2.40Pint
$8.50Prefilled Quarts
$11.50Banana Split
- Hard $10.00
- Soft Serve $7.50
Frozen Bananas
- Chocolate Dipped $1.00
Floats
- Hard $6.75
- Soft Serve $5.00
Jr Banana Split
- Hard $8.00
- Soft Serve $5.75
Novelties
Ice Cream Cookie
- (ea) $1.25
- Dozen $12.50
Cannoli
$3.50Color Changing
$2.50
cups or bowls
Logo
- Shirts $20.00
Toppings
Free Sprinkles
Pecans
$0.80Walnuts
$0.80Almonds
$0.80Strawberry
$0.80Hot Fudge
$0.80P.B. Sauce
$0.80Boba
$0.80Nerds
$0.80Cot. Candy Crunch
$0.80M & M's
$0.80Andes Mints
$0.80Whipped Cream
$0.80Peanuts
$0.80Cashews
$0.80Crunch Coat
$0.80Pineapple
$0.80Warm Caramel
$0.80Butter Scotch
$0.80Marshmallow
$0.80Gummi Bears
$0.80Cotton Candy Pops
$0.80PB Cups
$0.80Reese Pieces
$0.80Choc. Chips
$0.80Browse Nearby
General Info
Payment Types
All Major Cards
Cuisine
Dessert
Hours
Monday:
3:00pm - 9:00pm
Tuesday:
3:00pm - 9:00pm
Wednesday:
3:00pm - 9:00pm
Thursday:
3:00pm - 9:00pm
Friday:
3:00pm - 9:00pm
Saturday:
3:00pm - 9:00pm
Sunday:
3:00pm - 9:00pm
Additional Information:
Open for the 2025 Season starting April 1st thru September 30th. Will be closed on Easter Sunday.
About Us
Heavenly Creamery is a from scratch ice cream store in Conneaut Ohio. We make Premium Small Batch Custard on site. This year we've added Soft Serve Custard.