What's wrong with this menu?
Grey Lady - Montauk
440 W Lake Dr
Montauk, NY 11954
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
more menus
Beverages
Raw Bar
Food
Beverages
Cocktails
Sunset Spritz
Aperol Aperitivo, Stoli "O", Topped with Ca' del Doge Prosecco and Fresh Local Mixed Fruit
- (ea) $14.00
- Carafe $60.00
Spicy Watermelon Margarita
Jalapeño Infused Viva Tequila, Fresh Watermelon, Fresh Lime
- (ea) $14.00
- Carafe $60.00
Lady's Southside
Gluten-Free Gin, Local Cucumber, Basil, Lemon, Ca' Del Doge Prosecco
- (ea) $14.00
- Carafe $60.00
Dark & Sexy
Gosling's Black Seal Rum, Coconut Puree, Lime, Topped with Gosling's Ginger Beer and Candied Ginger
- (ea) $14.00
- Carafe $60.00
BBJ
Old Forester Bourbon, Blackberry Puree, Lemon, Fresh Mint
- (ea) $14.00
- Carafe $60.00
Grey Lady Mule
Stoli Elit Vodka, Owen's Craft Ginger, Angostura Bitters, Fresh Mint
- (ea) $14.00
- Carafe $60.00
Smoke N' Strawberry
Se Busca Mezcal, Cointreau, Strawberry Syrup, Grapefruit, Lime Juice, Local Berries
- (ea) $14.00
- Carafe $60.00
Frozen Selection
$18.00
Please Ask Your Server
Rosé + Bubbles
House Rosé, Nicolas Idiart NV, Provence, FR
- $11.00
- $44.00
Notorious Pink Rosé 2018, Herault, FR
- $12.00
- $48.00
Wölffer Rosé 2018, Sagaponack, USA
- $14.00
- $56.00
Notorious Pink Rosé, Magnum 2017, Herault, FR
$120.00Wölffer Sparkling Rosé, Magnum, "Noblesse" 2014, Sagaponack, USA
$225.00CA' del Dodge Prosecco, Prosecco, IT
- $12.00
- $48.00
Veuve Clicquot Brut Rosé Champange, Reims FR
$185.00Veuve Clicquot Brut Champange, Reims FR
$175.00Cans
Bucket of Claws -or- Beers: 6 White Claws or Rosé Cider, 6 Beers (See Selection Below)
Tecate
- $7.00
- $35.00
Montauk Wave Chaser IPA
- $8.00
- $40.00
Montauk Summer Ale
- $8.00
- $40.00
Bud Light
- $6.00
- $30.00
Kona Big Wave Ale
- $8.00
- $40.00
Wölffer Rosé Cider
- $12.00
- $60.00
White Claw Mango
- $8.00
- $40.00
White Claw Black Cherry
- $8.00
- $40.00
White
House Sauvignon Blanc, Hei Matau, Marlborough, NZ
- $12.00
- $48.00
Pinot Grigio, CA' del Doge, Veneto, IT
- $11.00
- $44.00
Chardonnay, Laurel Lake 2015 Reserve, North Fork, USA
- $14.00
- $56.00
Riesling, Jamesport 2017, North Fork, USA
- $13.00
- $52.00
Sancerre, Reverdy Ducroux 2017, Loire, FR
- $16.00
- $64.00
East Coast Oysters
Let's Get Shucked up
East Coast Oysters
Montauk Pearl (Montauk, NY), Malpeque (P.E.I. CAN), Beausoleil (New Brunswick, CAN)
- (each) $3.00
- Half Dozen $17.00
- Dozen $33.00
For the Table
Jonah Crab Toast
$19.00
Jonah Crab, Herb Mayo, Dill, Lemon
Crispy Calamari
$18.00
Chili & Soy Glaze, Pickled Peppers, Thai Basil
Roasted Cauliflower
$14.00
Ají Amarillo, Pickled Onion, Breadcrumbs, Brown Butter
Shrimps on Shrimp (4pc)
$17.00
Spicy Shrimp, Green Papaya Salad, Shrimp Crackers, Peanuts
Smoked Trout Pâté
$15.00
Horseradish, Chive, Lemon
Salads
ADD: Grilled Chicken (+$6), Shrimp (+$9), Crispy Squid (+$6), or Avocado (+$4)
Burrata Salad
$16.00
Market Vegetables, Watermelon Radish, Olive, Basil Oil
Market Green Salad
$13.00
Mixed Greens, Red Onion, Cherry Tomatoes, Housemade Croutons, Sherry Vinaigrette
Kale Caesar Salad
$13.00
Almond, Parmesan, Caesar Dressing
Plates
Lady's Lobster Roll
Freshly Shucked Maine Lobster, Served Cold With Mayo, Fries
- MP
Seafood Linguine
$29.00
Shrimp, Clams, Mussels, Grilled Calamari, Herb Breadcrumbs, Parmesan Cheese
Line-Caught Local Striped Bass
$39.00
Pan-Seared Filet, Roasted Cherry Tomatoes & Potatoes, Seaweed Butter
Grilled Fish Tacos (3)
$25.00
Fish Of The Day, Purple Cabbage, Cilantro, Chipotle, Pico De Gallo, Salsa Verde, Lemon, Crema Sauce, Arbol Chili Sauce
Fried Seafood Platter
$32.00
Fish Of The Day, Calamari, Shrimp, French Fries, Served With Tartar Sauce And Coleslaw
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
$18.00
Buttermilk Fried Chicken, Aji Amarillo Sauce, LT, Fries
Grey Lady Burger
$19.00
La Frieda Blend, Cheddar, LTO, Horseradish Mayo