What's wrong with this menu?
Good Steer
2810 Middle Country Rd
Lake Grove, NY 11755
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
more menus
Main Menu
Party Menu
Wine Menu
"Good" Kids Menu
Main Menu
Good Starts
Garlic Fry Basket
$7.95
Idaho Fries tossed with Garlic Butter and Olive Oil Dressing. Topped with a sprinkle of Romano Cheese! Basket
Rib Sampler
$10.25
Over One Pound of Pork Spare Ribs Cut up for munching
Rochester Wings
$9.95
Slowly Smoked over Hickory Wood. Finished in our zesty sauce! Celery sticks, Hot Sauce and Made-Here Real Bleu Cheese Dressing
Skinny Dippin'
$9.45
Deep fried Idaho potato skins or fries topped with Cheese Dream Sauce and bacon bits. Sour cream on the side
Fried Chicken Tenders
$11.95
Dipped in Blue Point Lager Batter and fried Golden Crunchy or Hand Breaded with Buttermilk and Herbs. With Honey Mustard OR Your Chioce of Buffalo Style with Blue Cheese Side Brushed with Hickory BarBeQue Sauce Garlic, Butter, Olive Oil Dressing, Parmesan Sprinkle
Crispy Fried Buffalo Chicken Tenders
$11.95
Tossed with a buttery hot sauce, served with Bleu Cheese Dressing and celery sticks
You've Got Some Quesadilla
A flour tortilla filled with three melted cheeses. Creole Sauce and Sour Cream on the side
- $9.25
- Add BBQ Beef or BBQ Chicken or BBQ Pork $3.50
- Add BBQ Pork $3.50
- Add BBQ Chicken $3.50
It's Chili in here!
$7.45
Made with 3 beans and Good Steer Beef. Topped with melted Mozzarella or Sour Cream
L.I. Clam Chowder or Our Other "Good" Soup
$6.00It's a Crock of Delicious French Onion Soup
$6.95
Baked with a French Bread Crouton and topped with melted mozzarella chees
Nachos
Tortilla Chips with Dream Sauce, Melted Shredded Cheeses, Chopped Peppers, Red Onion, Diced Tomatoes, Olives and jalapenos. Topped with house made creole sauce and Sour Cream.
- $10.95
- Add BBQ Pulled Pork, Beef Brisket, Chicken or Chil $3.50
Sandwiches & Wraps
All Sandwiches served with Idaho Fries Sweet Potato Fries instead of Idaho Fries. $0.60 extra
Nashville Barbecue Sandwich
$14.45
Pulled Beef Brisket or Iowa Pork or a blend of White and Dark Meat Chicken, Hickory smoked overnight and piled high on a toasted roll or wrap with BBQ sauce and our famous Onion Rings. Dream Sauce on the side
Open Faced Roast Beef Croissant
$17.95
With potato and onion ring garnish. Served with French dip
Cheese 'n Turkey Melt
$13.25
Sliced Fresh Roasted Turkey....grilled on whole wheat bread with Swiss cheese, tomatoes and Russian dressing
Philly Cheese Steak Wrap
$14.45
Thinly sliced Prime Rib of Beef and French Fried Onion Rings rolled in a warm wrap with melted Swiss Cheese and "Good" Steak Sauce
Chicken Breast Sandwich
$13.95
Choose Garlic & Oil Grilled or Batter Dipped Deep Fried Chicken Breast. Served on a toasted roll with lettuce, tomato and Idaho Fries
Twin Maryland Style Crab Cake Roll
$14.45
Two fried Crab Cakes on a toasted roll with lettuce, sliced tomatoes, Creole OR Tartar sauce
"Good" Turkey Club
$17.45
A double-decker dandy of sliced Fresh Roasted Turkey, crisp bacon, sliced tomato, lettuce and mayonnaise on Sliced European White Toast. Served with made-here Redskin Potato Salad or Idaho Fries
Grilled Deli Delight with Corned Beef or Turkey
$17.45
Sliced Cured-Here Corned Brisket or Fresh Roasted Turkey layered with Sauerkraut and Swiss Cheese in a warm wrap or on grilled Rye Bread. Served with Redskin Potato Salad OR Idaho Fries. Russian dressing if you like
Good Steer Burgers
Idaho Fries added to any of the Burger Selections $1.95 extra
The Original Burger Supreme
Over one-third pound of lean, freshly ground, Char-broiled Steer Burger on a toasted Martin's seeded or unseeded roll, garnished with our World Famous Onion Rings with Idaho fries, cole slaw and pickle chips. Sweet Potato: Fries instead of Idaho Fries
- $11.95
- Sweet Potato (extra) $1.00
Twin Double Supreme
$17.95
Two Steerburgers served open faced on a freshly toasted English Muffin - one topped with Cheese Dream Sauce, the other with bacon strips. Idaho Fries and French fried onion rings
Classic Cheese Dream Supreme
$15.25
A Steerburger topped with sliced tomato, creamy Dream Sauce, bacon strips, Idaho Fries and, of course, our French fried onion rings
"Good" Creations
Add what you like!!
Garlic Idaho Fries
instead of Idaho Fries
- extra $1.00
Old-English Cheese
$1.00Farmland Bacon Strips
$1.00Lettuce and Sliced Tomato
- (per slice) $1.00
Thick Raw Onion
$1.00Sauteed Mushrooms
$1.00Sauteed Onions
$1.00Melted Mozzarella
$1.00Imported Swiss Cheese
$1.00Canadian Bacon
$1.00Monterey Jack Cheese
$1.00Bleu Cheese
$1.00Veggie Burger instead
$1.00Toasted Thomas' instead
$1.00Turkeyburger instead
no extra charge
Lettuce & Tomato instead of Fries
no extra charge
Beef
All Steaks are hand-cut, dry-aged, USDA choice or higher, American Beef. Available plain or marinated, Char or Flame Broiled. Substitute Whipped Sweet Potatoes, Baked Beans, Garlic Fries or Fresh Steamed Broccoli for Potato on any Dinner item at no charge. A small Caesar may be substituted for a Farmer Salad on any Steak or Beef dinner item at no extra charge
Legendary New York Shell Steak
A nicely broiled, juicy, boneless cut of aged U.S.D.A. Choice, or better, New York Shell Steak
- Over One Pound Cut $34.95
- Over Half Pound Cut $27.95
Tastefully Tender
A carefully marinated sliced Skirt Steak serve*d on grilled garlic toast
- $27.45
- With three melted cheeses $1.95
Platter of Hot Roast Beef
$23.95
Slow Roasted Top Round of Beef - Another Steer favorite!
Roasted Prime Rib of Beef
$29.95
A Boneless Cut of slow roasted, tender, juicy Steer Beef. Really "Good" (Limited Availability)
Sea for Yourself!
Served with a Farmer Salad or Cole Slaw, and a choice of potato or seasoned rice or Nashville Country Beans. Broiled seafood is prepared with parsley butter, lemon or scampi butter. Clam Chowder or Soup may be substituted for a Farmer Salad or Cole Slaw, on any dinner offering, at no extra charge
Fish 'n' Chips
$19.95
North Atlantic Cod Dipped in Blue Point Lager Batter, Southern Fried Golden Brown
Chicken
A small Caesar may be substituted for a Farmer Salad on any dinner item at no extra charge
Crunchy Chicken Tenders
$21.00
Hand-breaded to order, prepared in Cholesterol & Trans-fat free oil. Honey Mustard dipping sauce or Spice it up Buffalo Style. served with Farmer Salad OR Cole Slaw, choice of Potato OR Nashville Country Beans OR Seasoned Rice. Biscuits and Corn Muffins
Down Home Barbecue Cookin'
$21.00
Half a Chicken...smoked with hickory and apple wood and brushed with "good" barbecue sauce! Served up fine with chilled potato salad, cole slaw, sliced tomatoes and lettuce
The Salad Side
Salad Dressing Choices: Russian, Danish Bleu, Country French, Vinaigrette, Honey Mustard, Lite Ranch and Italian Lite. Plus Olive Oil and Wine or Balsamic Vinegar
Market Salad
$8.50
Fresh mixed greens, crisp Iceberg & Romaine lettuce with diced tomato, raw red onion, shaved carrots, pepper rings and made-here garlic, herb and oil croutons
Praise Caesar
$8.25
Chilled Fresh Romaine Lettuce tossed with DiCesare Dressing, garnished with house-made herb croutons and a Parmesan sprinkle
Marinated Steak Over Salad
$17.95
Sliced marinated skirt steak over mixed green salad, vegetable garnishes, topped with French fried onion rings and served in a made to order fresh edible tortilla bowl.Choice of dressing served on the side
It's Berrry Good!
Mixed Spring Greens with Red Onion, Dried Cranberries, and Crunchy Southern Pecans. Topped with Goat Cheese and Diced Tomato. Raspberry Balsamic Vinaigrette
- $9.65
- Add a Top $3.50
Chicken Caesar Wrap
$12.65
Fresh, chilled Caesar Salad tossed with Grilled Chicken folded into a warm Wrap. Served with Idaho Fries
Fresh Chicken Salad Wrap
$12.65
Freshly made White Meat Chicken Salad, prepared with Hellman's Mayonnaise, rolled in a wrap with diced tomatoes, chopped bacon and some lettuce leaves. Served with Zero Trans-fat Sweet Potato Fries
Turkey or Steer Burger Plate
Large Fresh Farmer Salad with crisp, fresh veggies, topped with either a Turkey OR Steer Burger with raw red onion. Dressing choice served on the side
- $12.25
- Garnished with French Fried Onions Rings (extra) $1.95
Topping
Tops for your Farmer's Market, BBLT or Caesar Salad. Any Salad Garnished with Onion Rings $1.95 extra
Fried Chicken Breast
$3.50Grilled Chicken Breast
$3.50Barbecue Pulled Chicken
$3.50Three Coconut Shrimp
$3.50Good Sides
Basket of World Famous French Fried Onion Rings
$6.25Basket of Idaho Fries
$5.65Basket of Sweet Spuds!
$5.95
Zero Trans-fat Sweet Potato Fries
Carefully Baked Idaho Potatoes
Loaded with Dream Sauce and real bacon bits (Offered all day for lunch and dinner)
- $4.65
- with real sour cream $3.20
Redskin Potato Salad
$3.95Whipped Sweet Potatoes
$3.95Garlic Fry Basket
Idaho Fries tossed with Seasoned Fresh Garlic Butter and Olive Oil Dressing. Topped with a sprinkle of Romano Cheese. A Great Appetizer to Share or with a Burger
- A Basket $6.95
- Instead on a Burger $0.60
Fresh Side Caesar Salad
$4.95World Famous Cole Slaw
$3.70Farmer Salad, Choice of Dressing
$3.95Pitcher of Cheese Dream Sauce
$3.45Nashville Country Baked Beans
$3.70Seasoned Steamed Rice
$2.95Fresh Steamed Broccoli
$3.45Baked Macaroni and Cheese
$5.25
Imported Pasta baked in a crock with Four Cheeses. Topped with Seasoned Bread Crumbs or Plain
Whites
Chardonnay
From Hess, California. Refreshing flavors with a smooth finish. Vivian's Pick
- by-the-glass $6.00
Pinot Grigio
Ponticello from Venezie May be served with all of your favorite dishes - Linda's Pick
- by-the-glass $6.00
Sauvignon Blanc
Pierre Chainier "1749" Liore, France. Well balanced, crisp and refreshing
- by-the-glass $6.00
Reds
Pinot Noir
Red Truck from Sonoma. A medium bodied wine with a smooth spiciness. Trey likes trucks!
- by-the-glass $6.00
Cabernet Sauvignon
Sonoma County, Domaino St. George. Straight forward Cab great with Beef! - Bob's Pick
- by-the-glass $6.00
Blush - Sparkling
White Zinfandel
Sutter Home Is the original White Zin. It goes nicely with everything!
- by-the-glass $6.00
Sparkling Wine
Method Champenois, Domaine Laurier, California. (187 milliliter)
- by-the-glass $6.00
Beer
Pints From the Barrel. Ask your server about Special Seasonal Beers
Blue Point Toasted Lager
$6.50Long Ireland Celtic Ale
$6.50Bass Ale
$6.50Heineken
$6.50Budweiser
$5.50Bud Light
$5.50Beverages
Fresh Hot Regular or Decaffeinated Coffee
$2.00Fresh Brewed Lipton Tea Regular or Decaf
$2.00Hot Chocolate with whipped cream
$2.50Arizona Iced Tea, Sweetened or Unsweetened , Green Tea with Ginseng and Honey, "Arnold Palmer 1/2 Tea, 1/2 Lemonade.
$2.65Poland Spring Bottled Water, 16.9 oz
$2.35Ice Cold Lemonade
$2.95Segram's Ginger Ale
$2.95Coca Cola
$2.95Diet Coke
$2.95Draft Root Beer
$2.95Original and Diet
$2.95Hi-C Fruit Punch
$2.95Dr. Pepper
$2.95Sprite and Orange Cream
$2.95Super Slurper Ice Cream Soda
$5.45
Topped with whipped cream and a cherry!
Like the "Good" Old Days
$5.45
Malted Milk Shake Vanilla, Chocolate or Strawberry
Bobs Smokehouse
Good" Ribbin' Dinner
Barbecue Pork Ribs, Slow Smoked, overnight, with Apple and HickoryWood brushed with a zesty Barbecue Sauce. Served with French Fried Onion Rings, Farmer Salad or Cole Slaw, Choice of Potato or Seasoned Rice, Biscuits and Corn Muffins
- Full Rack $27.50
- Half Rack $19.95
Barbecue "Good" Starts!
Rib Sampler
$10.25
Over One Pound of Cut-up Pork Ribs. Very Popular!
"Good" Stuff Beginner
$13.25
Barbecue Rochester Wings and Cut-up Pork Ribs. Great for sharing!
Rochester Wings
$9.95
Smoked over Hickory wood and brushed with a zesty sauce. Served with Celery sticks, Bleu Cheese Dressing and Winger Sauce
Barbecue Sandwiches
Nashville Barbecue Sandwich
$14.45
Pulled Beef Brisket or Iowa Pork or White and Dark Meat Chicken, Hickory smoked overnight and piled high on a toasted roll or wrap with BBQ sauce and our famous Onion Rings, Idaho Fries, Cole Slaw and Pickle Chips. Cheese Dream Sauce on the side
Smokehouse Dinners
"Good" Stuff
$26.25
Barbecue Rochester Wings together with Cut-up Pork Ribs. Slathered with Barbecue Sauce... this is a real Smokehouse Combination Treat! Served with French Fried Onion Rings, Farmer Salad or Cole Slaw, Choice of Potato or Seasoned Rice and Biscuits and Corn Muffins
Pitmaster Plate
A Tasty sample of (3) Spare Ribs, Paired with (2) BBQ Meats, Pulled Pork, Pulled Brisket or Pulled White/Dark Meat Chicken. Served with Onion Rings, Farmer Salad or Slaw. Choice of Potato, Rice or Country Baked Beans
- $25.95
- Enjoy as an Appetizer $18.45
Down Home Cookin'!
$21.00
Half a Barbecue Chicken - Smoked with Hickory and Apple Wood and brushed with "Good" Barbecue Sauce. Served with Chilled Potato Salad, Cole Slaw, Sliced Tomatoes on Lettuce. Biscuits and Corn Muffins
Main
St. Louis Style Pork Back Spare Ribs
Slow Smoked with Apple and hickory wood, cut up for munching. Can be prepared hot or cold, with or with-out sauce or Sauce on the side
- Half tray (Serves 4-6) $49.95
- Full Tray (Serves 8-10) $89.95
Rochester Wings
slow smoked over hickory wood with a zesty sauce. served with celery sticks and bleu cheese. Prepared hot or cold, with or with-out sauce or Sauce on the side, Mild or Spicy
- Half tray (Serves 4-6) $43.95
- Full Tray (Serves 8-10) $83.95
Deep Fried Chicken Fingers
Breaded or Battered, with Honey Mustard Sauce Spicey Buffalo Style or Hickory BBQ with Blue Cheese Dressing. Garlic, Butter, Herb and Olive Oil with a Parmesan Sprinkle
- Half tray (Serves 4-6) $46.95
- Full Tray (Serves 8-10) $78.95
Hickory Smoked BBQ Beef Brisket, Pork
$49.95
Butt or white and dark meat pulled chicken. By the 1/2 Tray (Makes about 15 big ol' sandwiches, comes with 2/8pc packages of "Big Marty's" seeded rolls) Prepared hot or cold, with or without sauce or Sauce on the side
Good Steer DiCesare Salad
$24.95
With Fresh Made Here Dressing, by the 1/2 tray
Baked Macaroni and Cheese
Imported pasta with FOUR Cheeses, topped with seasoned bread crumbs if you like
- 1/2 Tray $29.95
Nashville Country Baked Beans
With a hint of Smoke
- (per Quart) $9.95
Bob's Famous Chili
this is bob's secret chili recipe. it's so secret he doesn't even know what goes into it
- (Per Quart) $9.95
Our World Famous Deep Fried Onion Rings
- Basket Size $6.95
- 1/2 Tray $18.95
Idaho Fries
Try a Pint of Butter, Garlic and Olive Oil Fry Dressing $4.25
- Basket $6.95
- 1/2 Tray $18.95
Almost World Famous Cole Slaw
We make it here, fresh every day!!!
- (Per Quart) $7.25
Good Steer Red Skin Potato Salad
We make it here too!!!
- (Per Quart) $8.95
Cheese Dream Sauce
- Pint $12.50
- Quart $22.95
Fried, Roast or BBQ Chicken
served cold or hot
2 1/2 Chickens
$46.95
5ea. Breast, Thigh, wing and drumstick
5 Chickens
$78.95
10ea. Breast, Thigh, wing and drumstick
Some Really "Good" Specials
Good Wraps
Choose from a combination of Grilled Chicken, Roast Beef, Turkey, Ham or Corned Beef. Chicken, Tuna or Lobster Salad. Grilled Vegetable, American, Swiss, Mozzerella or Monterey Jack Cheeses with lots of toppings and condiments. Wrapped in flour or whole wheat tortillas. Mayo, Mustard, Honey Mustard etc. on the side. We have some "Good" Wrap ideas for you, Give us a call!
- (12 wraps) $39.95
- (24 wraps) $68.95
Sauerbraten Style Beef Brisket
In Ginger Snap Gravy with Red Cabbage and Mashed Potatoes
- 1/2 Tray $49.95
Sabrette All-Beef Franks
Steamed Natural Casing Franks with Sauerkraut. Comes with Martin's Potato Rolls & Guldens Spicy Brown Mustard
- 1/2 Tray, 16 Franks $39.95
- Full Tray, 32 Franks $68.95
- Add a Quart of Chili $9.95
- Add a Quart of Cheese Dream Sauce $22.95
Made Here Soups!
$9.25
Enjoy our Most Popular Made Here by the Quart! Manhattan Clam Chowder, Crème of Turkey, Beef Barley, Split Pea with Ham, Creamy Tomato with Tortellini. Westminster Oyster Crackers from Vermont!
Marinated Steak and Onion Rings!
3oz (approximate weight)pieces of Marinated Skirt Steak on a bed of our World Famous Onion Rings.
- (15 pieces) $49.95
- (30 pieces) $94.95
Sweets
Baked Here Pies
Pumpkin, Apple or Blueberry
- (each) $16.25
New Yorl Style Cheesecake
Baked here with a graham cracker crust
- $32.95
- Sweet Strawberry Puree by the pint $4.25
Special Cheesecakes
$34.95
Any of our Special Cheesecakes can be made especially for your party!
Rice Pudding
An Original McCarroll Family recipe! Topped with cinnamon
- 1/2 tray $32.00
- Sweet Strawberry Puree by the pint $3.95
Aunt Liz's Apple Crisp
Steer-baked apple "good'ness with raisins and a cinnamon crumb crisp topping
- 1/2 tray $36.95
White
Pinot Grigio
Coppiere, Venezie, Italy. Pinot Grigio comes to mind as the "Italian White Wine" with good reason! This one is crisp and light-bodied. A natural pairing for light dishes such as appetizers, salads, or fish.
- $24.00
- $8.50
Chardonnay
Hess, California. Very forthright Chardonnay. Refreshing Fresh Fruit Flavors, Cool Crisp, Easy to Drink! Great with Fish, Chicken or Salads.
- $24.00
- $8.50
Red
Cabernet Sauvignon
Sonoma County, Domaine St. George. Rich and Flavorful. Straight forward Cab with soft yet intense, lingering sensation. A Natural Standard with Prime Rib and Steaks!
- $25.00
- $8.50
Merlot
Graton, Appellation, California, Russian River Valley. Soft and rich with smooth red berry and plummy notes and a lingering finish. Goes especially well with Burgers and Marinated Steaks.
- $24.00
- $8.50
Blush & Sparkling Wine
White Zinfandel, Sutter Home, California
White Zinfandel, Sutter Home, California. Light bodied and refreshingly cool. The Original White Zin!
- $20.00
- $8.50
Good Finishes
New York Style Deep Dish Cheesecake
$7.25
We bake it here with a Graham Cracker Crust. Original topped with Whipped Cream or Strawberry Sauce. Ask about our Special Cheesecake!
Aunt Liz's Apple Crisp
$6.95
Steer made Apple "Goodness" served warm with a scoop of Ice Cream
W.W.B. - Wonderful Warm Brownie
$6.95
Topped with Ice Cream, Hot Fudge and Whipped Cream
Grandma's Baked Here Apple Pie
- by the slice $4.95
- Add for a Scoop or Ice Cream $1.00
Creamy Rice Pudding
$5.95
A McCarroll Family Original Since We opened in 1957! With Strawberry Sauce or Whipped Cream
Over & Under
$6.95
Premium Vanilla Ice Cream Over Toasted Pound Cake Under Hot Fudge
Classic Hot Fudge or Strawberry Sundae
$6.55
A "two spooner" made with vanilla or chocolate Ice Cream and topped with Whipped Cream and a Cherry!
Cookie Skillet Sundae
$7.95
A Triple Chocolate Chip Cookie baked in an Iron Skillet. Served warm with Ice Cream, Hot Fudge and Whipped Cream
Good Kids Menu
Our Good Kids Menu items include a choice of Idaho Fries, Steamed Broccoli or Apple Sauce. A junior Lemonade, Fountain Soda or an Apple or Fruit Punch juice box or Milk. Chocolate Pudding, Chocolate Chip Cookies or an Ice Cream Dixie Cup to enjoy here or take home.
Chicken Little
$6.95
Char Grilled or Fried Chicken Tenders
Battered Codfish
$6.95
Lightly Fried to order
Steer Puncher
All Beef Hamburger - cooked Medium Well Only
- $6.95
- (with Cheese) $7.95
Cheese Please
$6.95
a "Good" Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Frankly Speaking
$6.95
A Grilled All Beef Sabrette Frankfurter on a roll
Macs and Cheese
$6.95
Baked in a crock - Potato or Broccoli NOT included
Kids Prime Rib
$9.95
a 6oz cut or Prime Rib or Beef (Limited Availability)
Browse Nearby
General Info
Payment Types
All Major Cards
Cuisine
American - Traditional
BBQ
Burgers
Sandwiches
Steakhouse
Meals
Lunch
Dinner
Hours
Monday:
12:00pm - 10:00pm
Tuesday:
12:00pm - 10:00pm
Wednesday:
12:00pm - 10:00pm
Thursday:
12:00pm - 10:00pm
Friday:
12:00pm - 10:00pm
Saturday:
12:00pm - 10:00pm
Sunday:
12:00pm - 10:00pm
Additional Information:
Closed for Thanksgiving, Christmas (close at 8 on Christmas Eve and 9 on New Years Eve) and Easter so our Good Folks can be home with their families!
About Us
Since 1957, The Good Steer has been providing customers with outstanding food, a warm and cozy d