Gatsby's is proud to be one of the few restaurants in the country to offer this wonderfully flavored Lamb from Elysian Fields in Southwestern, Pennsylvania
Miller Livestock Beef , Truffle Cheddar, Balsamic Onions, Herb Aioli Chargrilled Tomato, Brioche Bun, Fresh Cut Fries
Miller Livestock Farm to Table Feature
Ask about our current offering from Miller Livestock in nearby Kinsman, Ohio
Market Price
Gatsby's Prime Selections
14 oz New York Strip
$32.00
16 oz Rib Eye
$42.00
Center Cut Filet
6 oz$28.00
8 oz$32.00
Prime Additions
Rosemary Red Wine Sauce
$1.75
Bordelaise Sauce
$1.50
Gorgonzola Cream Sauce
$1.50
Sautéed Onions, Peppers or Mushrooms
$2.25
Crumble Bleu
$2.75
Shrimp Scampi
$5.50
Butter Poached Crab
$10.00
Additional Lobster Tail
Market
Accompaniments
Roasted Brussels Sprouts
$3.00
Roasted Asparagus
$3.75
Broccoli with Garlic and Roasted Red Pepper
$3.00
Butter Braised Redskins*
$3.00
White Cheddar and Rosemary Smashed Potatoes
$3.00
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
$3.00
Boursin and Wild Mushroom Risotto
$3.00
Roasted Garlic Risotto
$3.00
*Substitute the Traditional Side Salad with any Pasta or Entrée for any salad with a $3 discount
Wines by the Glass
White & Rosé
Chardonnay, Quilt 2016 Napa Valley, California
Medium bodied with complex layers and a silky texture. Long satiny finish
Glass$8.00
Bottle$30.00
Chardonnay, Mcmanis 2016, California
Fruity, floral aromas. Notes of pear, jasmine, ripe peach and a hint of vanilla
Glass$6.00
Bottle$22.00
Blend, Conundrum, California
Scents of apricot, pineapple, honeysuckle. Soft, with lush tropical flavors
Glass$8.00
Bottle$29.00
Pinot Grigio, Terlato 2016, Friuli, Italy
Notes of ripe peach, apricot, pear. Mouth filling texture and crisp, mineral finish
Glass$7.00
Bottle$29.00
Sauvignon Blanc, Honig 2017, Napa Valley
Bright crisp and fresh. Peaches, pear lime, grapefruit. Floral and tropical
Glass$8.00
Bottle$30.00
Rosé of Pinot Noir, Rodney Strong 2017, Russian River Valley
Delightful brightness. Strawberry notes. Crisp acidity and a clean, elegant finish
Glass$7.00
Bottle$28.00
Viognier, Mcmanis 2016, California
Aromas of apricot and honey are accompanied by underlying mineral notes
Glass$6.00
Bottle$22.00
Chiarle, Moscato d'Asti, Piedmont Italy
Easy to love sweet wine with flavors of nectarine, honey and peach
Glass$7.00
Bottle$30.00
Riesling, Von Wilhelm Haus, Mosel, Germany
Sweeter style Riesling with tropical notes
Glass$6.00
Bottle$22.00
Coravin - Premium Selections
Chardonnay, Rombauer 2017, Carneros
Rich and creamy, with seductive vanilla-scented oak that adds texture and nuance to the solid core of green apple, pear and melon flavors
Glass$13.00
Bottle$55.00
Chardonnay, Chateau Montelena 2015, Napa Valley
A gorgeous wine. Candied lemon, white flowers and mint are nicely textured. Soft, enveloping and gracious
Glass$14.00
Bottle$65.00
Chardonnay, Cakebread 2016, Napa Valley
Vivid, creamy aromas of green and golden apple, pear and citrus with supporting scents of beeswax and mineral. Full-bodied and vibrant on the palate, with bright, intense, apple, citrus and melon flavors
Glass$14.00
Bottle$65.00
Viognier, E. Guigal Condrieu 2017, Rhone, France
Brilliant clear golden yellow. Intensely flowery (violets), and fruity (apricot, peaches and citrus). Fresh and round. Rich, unctuous and full bodied
Glass$20.00
Bottle$95.00
Sparkling
Brut, House Prosecco, Italy
Glass$7.00
Bottle$22.00
Brut Rose, Chandon, California
Glass (187ml)$10.00
Brut, Chandon, California
Glass (187ml)$12.00
Demi-Sec, Moet & Chandon Nectar Imperial Rose, Champagne
Glass (187ml)$22.00
Prosecco, Bollincini, Veneto, Italy
Glass (187ml)$6.00
Fortified & Dessert
Dows Fine Tawny Port, Portugal
Glass$5.00
Calem Ten Year Tawny Port, Portugal
Glass$8.00
Noval Twenty Year Tawny Port, Portugal
Glass$15.00
Dows Thirty Year Tawny Port, Portugal
Glass$24.00
Noval Forty Year Tawny Port, Portugal
Glass$30.00
Alvear 1927 Solera Pedro Jimenez Sherry, Spain
Glass$10.00
Lambert Chocolate Port, Australia
Glass$5.00
Noval Ruby Port, Portugal
Glass$5.00
Red
Cabernet Sauvignon, Austin Hope 2016, Paso Robles, California
Big, powerful, modern wine with velvety tannins and heaps of juicy blackberry
Glass$10.00
Bottle$50.00
Cabernet Sauvignon, Mcmanis 2017, California
Smooth, medium-bodied. Lots of ripe berries and a good mix of oak spices
Glass$7.00
Bottle$26.00
Cabernet Blend, Gabrielle Vertex NV, North Coast, California
Aromas of black fruits with flavors of wild blackberry and dark chocolate
Glass$9.00
Bottle$38.00
Chianti, Lamole di Lamole Chianti Classico 2013, Tuscany Italy
A perennial favorite, rich in nuances of oak, spices, and sweet fruits
Glass$8.00
Bottle$33.00
Merlot, Mcmanis 2017, Californiaf
Ripe berry flavors mingle with hints of toffee. The finish is soft and smooth
Glass$7.00
Bottle$26.00
Pinot Noir, Wente 2014 'Riva Ranch', Monterey, California
Beautiful aromas and flavors of cherry and red apple with notes of black tea
Glass$8.00
Bottle$30.00
Zinfandel, Klinker Brick 2015, Lodi, California
87 year old Vines! Berries and spice on the nose, dark, sweet fruit fills the palate
Glass$9.00
Bottle$35.00
Carmenere, Errazuiz 2013, Single Vineyard, Chile
Well balanced, juicy palate with notes of black fruits & fig over a spicy base
Aromas of freshly muddled boysenberries, warm vanilla bean and toasty cardamom. Voluminous and supple aromas, rich tannins and dark fruit
Glass$12.00
Bottle$50.00
Cabernet Sauvignon, Jordan, Alexander Valley 2014, Sonoma
A wine with elegance, refinement. Aromas of blackberries & black cherries subtle oak notes. Flavors of chocolate, violets and dark fruits. Long finish
Glass$18.00
Bottle$82.00
Cabernet Sauvignon, Jayson 2016, Napa Valley
By Pahlmeyer. Deep, elegant black fruit aromas, and hints of plum, licorice, vanilla, fresh cream and forest floor. A dense mid-palate; mocha, dusty chalk, and attractive herbal hints
Glass$22.00
Bottle$99.00
Cabernet Sauvignon, Orin Swift 'mercury Head' 2015, Napa Valley
Finely structured with supple tannins, this elegant wine can also be enjoyed following years in the cellar. Known for its perfect balance of power and finesse
Glass$32.00
Bottle$180.00
Cabernet Sauvignon, Favia 2014, Coombsville, Napa Valley
From the winemaker of Screaming Eagle, Andy Erickson. Earthy, Chocolaty, hints of anise, cherry. Incredibly pure and seamless
Glass$60.00
Bottle$275.00
Cabernet Sauvignon, Mira 2013 Stags Leap, Napa Valley
Spice filled aromas of cinnamon, violets and French vanilla dazzle the nose as sweet cacao, fresh grapes and anise tantalize the palate
Glass$28.00
Bottle$180.00
Cabernet Blend, Chateau Pavel de Luze 2013, Margaux, Bordeaux
Licorice, violet, good extraction in finesse. Nice freshness on a full, round palate, with fine tannins and a tender mouthfeel. The perfect companion for a rib of beef
Glass$12.00
Bottle$55.00
Cabernet Blend, Tenuta San Guido Sassicaia, Bolgheri 2015, Tuscany, Italy
Wine Spectator 2018 #1 Wine of the Year 85% Cabernet Sauvignon
Glass$65.00
Bottle$320.00
Syrah, Plumpjack 2015, Napa Valley
A muscular backbone is layered with bold and rich flavors, offering notes of blackberry, mocha and savory licorice that build speed toward big but refined tannins
Glass$18.00
Bottle$80.00
Merlot, Andrew Will 2015, Columbia Valley, Washington
Silky round textured with a tight berry and chocolate character. Full to medium body, delicious fruit and a juicy finish
Aromas of roses, licorice and berry fruit with subtle notes of vanilla and tobacco. It has structured layered flavors, a round velvet-textured palate and a lingering finish
Glass$14.00
Bottle$70.00
Pinot Noir, Belle Glos 2016 Clark & Telephone, Santa Maria Valley
Deep scarlet-red with lush aromas of blackberry bramble. Sumptuous strawberry jam, ripe black cherry notes. Long lingering finish
Glass$15.00
Bottle$68.00
Brunello, Enzo Tiezzi, 2013, Tuscany, Italy
Intense deep garnet red. The aromas are intensely vinous with scents of ripe fruit and a light vanilla note. Full, harmonious with sensations of ripe fruits of the forest
Glass$18.00
Bottle$75.00
Zinfandel, Brochelle 2015, Paso Robles
Enormous concentration of elegantly perfumed and richly structured fruit on the palate. a perfect balance of spice, fruit and acidity
Glass$14.00
Bottle$60.00
White Wines of the World
Italy
Arneis, Marco Porello 'Camestri' 2017, Roero, Piedmont
Bottle$30.00
Pinot Grigio, Terlato 2016, Friuli
Bottle$29.00
Sauvignon Blanc, Comelli 2016, Friuli Colli Orientali