Fay's is your coffee shop. Fay's Evelyn Bay Coffee Shop has that local coffee house atmosphere and is close to home! Meet friends and enjoy a fresh selection of beverages and pastries. From homemade soups, tasty sandwiches and ice cream treats, you're always sure to enjoy good value. Fay's Evelyn Bay Coffee Shop in Charlotte, Michigan is located on the main street. This Charlotte coffee shop is family owned and serves Michigan roasted coffee beans by Evelyn Bay Coffee Co.