crab, fresh spinach, and cream cheese baked and topped with cheddar jack with freshly cooked corn tortilla chips
Boom Boom Shrimp
$12.99
wild caught red shrimp deep fried & tossed in our spicy boom boom sauce
Coconut Shrimp Bites
$13.99
wild caught red shrimp, hand-breaded with a pina colada dipping sauce
Oysters Crabafella*
oysters topped with creamy crab and spinach dip, bacon and beurre blanc sauce. one dozen.
market price
Baked Oysters*
topped with garlic butter, parmesan cheese, and house seasonings. one dozen.
market price
Fried Pickle Chips
$9.99
hand-breaded with our remoulade sauce
Braised Mac N Cheese
$16.99
slow cooked braised beef and white cheddar mac and cheese baked, topped with toasted panko
Crab Cake
$12.99
large Florida style cake loaded with lump crab meat with pepper jam sauce
Conch Fritters
$12.99
six house-made conch fritters, lightly fried, with honey mustard
Gator Bites
$13.99
Florida caught, hand-breaded with tangy cherry peppers and remoulade sauce
Bavarian Pretzel
$11.99
jumbo, lightly salted pretzel with chorizo queso
Avocado & Shrimp Ceviche*
$13.99
our house-made ceviche topped with avocado chunks, served with tortilla chips
Chicken Tenders
$12.99
Nashville Hot style with choice of ranch or blue cheese
Chips & Chorizo
$12.99
house-made kettle chips topped with blackened chicken, chorizo queso, sour cream, and green onions
Hand-Tossed Pizza
Our sauce is made only with the finest Marzano tomatoes, paired with imported New York dough, the freshest ingredients available, and topped with 100% mozzarella cheese.
Margherita
$16.99
house-made red sauce with fresh basil & mozzarella cheese
The New Yorker
$16.99
house-made red sauce with pepperoni & Italian sausage.
Try our World Famous original recipe loaded with hearty potatoes, freshly shucked clams, bacon, and house spices
Calamari Caesar Salad
$16.99
a classic caesar salad topped with crispy calamari and tangy cherry peppers, with garlic bread
Avocado Shrimp Salad*
$15.99
crisp spinach mixed with homemade mango salsa, pico de gallo, citrus marinated shrimp, banana chips, topped with sliced avocado, and paired with a mango pineapple vinaigrette
House Salad
$6.99
romaine and spring mix blend, topped with tomatoes, onions, croutons, and cheddar jack cheese
add a small House Salad to Your Meal for
$3.99
Classic Caesar Salad
$7.99
topped with grated parmesan cheese and croutons
add a small Caesar Salad to Your Meal For
$3.99
Salad Protein Add-Ons
Chicken Breast$7.99
Shrimp
Grouper
Tuna*$10.99
Mahi$9.99
Salmon$9.99
Boils!
served with one side
Crab & Shrimp
3/4lb Bairdi crab legs and 1/2 order of easy peel shrimp with corn on the cob, smoked sausage, and tossed in cajun or garlic sauce
market price
Seafood Feast
1.5lbs of Bairdi crab legs and a full order of easy peel shrimp with corn on the cob, smoked sausage, and tossed in cajun or garlic sauce
market price
Shrimp
a full pound of wild red shrimp, smoked sausage, and fresh corn tossed in cajun or garlic sauce
market price
Crab
Bairdi crab legs with corn on the cob and smoked sausage, and tossed in cajun or garlic sauce
3/4lb. market price
1.5lbs. market price
Add
Add 1/2lb of scallops to any boil
market price
Combo Platters
with two sides
Key West Combo
$25.99
grilled mahi and large wild red shrimp glazed with key lime honey mustard, with conch fritters
Surf & Turf*
12oz Chairman's reserve cut New York strip and your choice of Bairdi crab, grilled shrimp, or sea scallops.
market price
Coconut Combo
hand-breaded hogfish and wild caught royal red shrimp
market price
Grouper & Shrimp
fresh cut grouper filet and red shrimp served grilled, blackened or fried
market price
Crabby's Combo
$28.99
a fried trio of grouper nuggets, calamari and wild caught royal red shrimp
Onshore
with two sides
Loaded Chicken
$18.99
twin chicken breasts basted in sweet honey bbq and topped with bacon, onions and cheddar jack cheese
Memphis Style Baby Back Ribs
$28.99
Full Slab
Add Nashville Hot Chicken Tenders
$9.99
Add Fried Shrimp
$12.99
New York Strip*
$28.99
a 12oz Chairman's reserve cut, topped with garlic butter
Ranchero Chicken
$18.99
twin chicken breasts, blackened with fresh avocado salsa, melted pepperjack cheese, and ranchero sauce
Chicken Strips
$16.99
hand breaded with choice of sauce, Nashville Hot or BBQ
Offshore
with two sides
Red Gulf Grouper
a local favorite. served fried, grilled, blackened, or Caribbean style
market price
Fried Shrimp Dinner
$18.99
lightly dusted and fried
Grilled Shrimp Dinner
$18.99
two skewers of grilled shrimp
Mahi Fresca
$23.99
blackened and topped with fresh avocado salsa and ranchero sauce
Bairdi Crab
a house favorite! served traditional steamed or fire-roasted with garlic butter and old bay seasoning. 1.5 lbs
market price
Fish & Chips
$18.99
panko crusted Alaskan cod filets with sea salt and a malt vinegar mist, served with fries and one side
Ahi Tuna Steak*
$17.99
blackened medium-rare, with a side of our house made cusabi sauce
Sea Scallops
blackened on cheesy grits, topped with beurre blanc and green onion, served with one side.
market price
Coconut Hogfish
hand-breaded in Malibu coconut breading and fried golden brown
market price
Coconut Shrimp
$21.99
hand-breaded in Malibu coconut breading and fried golden brown
Atlantic Salmon
$21.99
grilled or blackened
Sandwiches
served with one side. Udi's gluten free bun for .99 upcharge
Fresh Gulf Grouper
fried, grilled, blackened, or Caribbean style
market price
Mahi Mahi
$15.99
grilled, blackened, or Caribbean style
Mahi Melt
$17.99
blackened and topped with sauteed onions and melted cheese on Cuban bread
Salmon BLT
$18.99
grilled salmon, thick cut bacon, with lettuce and tomato, served on toasted Cuban bread, served with lemon aioli
Sirloin Burger*
$12.99
1/2 lb angus beef and brisket blend
Black Bean Burger
$11.99
grilled and topped with sauteed onions
Turkey Burger
$11.99
chargrilled, low-fat, high protein, premium ground turkey
Nashville Hot Chicken
$13.99
fried and tossed in Nashville hot sauce
Crab Cake
$14.99
hand-pattied jumbo lump crab cake served with lemon aioli
lightly fried grouper, topped with cabbage, cheddar cheese, tangy baja sauce, chopped red onions, fresh cilantro and our salsa verde
market price
Tropical Mahi Mahi
$15.99
blackened mahi mahi, topped with cabbage, mango salsa, topped with cheddar cheese and our cilantro cream sauce
Boom Boom Shrimp
$16.99
fried shrimp tossed in boom boom sauce with cabbage and fresh cilantro
Chicken
$13.99
fried chicken fingers topped with cabbage, cheddar cheese, tangy baja sauce, chopped red onions, fresh cilantro and our salsa verde
Vegetarian
$12.99
our black bean burger grilled and topped with cabbage, cheddar cheese, fresh cilantro, chopped red onions, salsa verde and tangy baja sauce
Braised Beef
$17.99
shredded beef, cabbage, tangy baja sauce with fresh cilantro red onion.
Pastas
with garlic bread
Shrimp Pasta
$19.99
large wild red shrimp and linguine pasta tossed in our creamy alfredo sauce
Cajun Pasta
$18.99
linguine pasta tossed in a creamy cajun sauce with grilled chicken & smoked sausage, topped with parmesan cheese
Shrimp & Grits
$19.99
sauteed large wild red shrimp, smoked sausage, and piquillo peppers over cheesy grits
Chicken & Grits
$18.99
blackened chicken, smoked sausage, and piquillo peppers over cheesy grits
Sides
Fries
Cheesy Grits
Black Beans & Rice
House-Made Kettle Chips
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Island Coleslaw
1/2 Ear Fresh Corn
(seasonal availability)
Fresh Veggie
Caribbean Street Corn
Add to Substitute$2.99
Add a la Carte$5.99
Mac & Cheese
Add to Substitute$0.99
Add a la Carte$3.99
Desserts
Killer Key Lime Pie
Key West authentic award winning pie
Better Than Your Momma's Chocolate Cake
Beignets
traditional beignets with raspberry sauce
Sweet Willy's Ice Cream
Ask about our small-batched rotating flavors!
*Consuming raw or undercooked oysters, meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses, especially if you have a medical condition
Drinks on Tap
Rum Runner Bucket
A delicious blend of Cruzan Rum, blackberry brandy, creme de banana and tropical juices.
Available in 12oz, 20oz, or 32oz bucket
Margarita Bucket
Our classic margarita made with Hornitos Tequila
Available in 12oz and 20oz
Frozen Favorites
Key Lime in the Coconut
We put the key lime in the coconut and shake it all about, made with Cruzan Key Lime and a Myer's Dark Rum float.
Dirty Banana
Bacardi Rum, creme de cacao, Kahlua, banana puree and chocolate drizzle.
Perfect Pina Colada
Cruzan Coconut Rum, a vastly refreshing coconut mix, and a Myers Dark Rum floater.
Florida Sunset
Sauza tequila blended with triple sec and our famous mango mix. Layered atop our Strawberry mix to create the perfect Florida Sunset.
Tito's Shark Bite
Tito's Vodka blended with lemonade and blue curacao with a float of grenadine.
Beamsicle
Kentucky meets Florida with this Jim Beam Orange infused frozen favorite. A crafty twist on the traditional dreamsicle.
Coastal Cocktails
Coconut Mojito
RumHaven rum with fresh squeezed lime juice, mint, simple syrup and a splash of soda.
Strawberry Lemonade Mojito
Absolute Juice Strawberry Vodka mixed with fresh muddled lemons, mint leaves, strawberries, lemonade, and a splash of soda
Skinny Flamingo
Rum Haven Rum with organic strawberry sour mix, soda water, and fresh squeezed lemon juice.
Tito's American Lemonade
Refreshing mix of Tito's Handmade Vodka & lemonade. Mango, strawberry, raspberry, or make it twisted with an inverted Twisted Tea.
Available in 12oz or 20oz
Pelican Punch
Rum Haven rum with Organic strawberry sour mix, soda water, and fresh squeezed lemon juice.
Merica's Mule
Tito's Vodka with Gosling's Ginger beer and a fresh lime aqueeze.
Ritas & Grias!
Dosarita
a 12oz Dos Equis Lager turned face down in a Crabby's Classico Margarita. Best of both worlds! Stay thirsty!
Organic Margarita
Fresh from the earth with Tres Agaves tequila and all organic blend of margarita goodness.
Golden Crabarita
Crafted from scratch with Camarena Tequila, Tippler's Orange Liqueur, fresh orange juice, and our organic margarita mix.
Available as 12oz or 20oz
Sangrita
Can't decide? Try a delicious mix of our white sangria and our house margarita.
Watermelon Rita
Hornitos Tequila, with a blend of our house margarita mix, watermelon juice and a sugar rim.
White Peach
Fresh muddled strawberries, house white wine, apple juice, agave nectar, pineapple juice, watermelon juice, and peach schnapps.
Available 12oz, 20oz, or a Pitcher
Berry Red
House red wine with muddled cherries, oranges, and limes, then mixed with blackberry brandy and lemon lime soda.
Available 12oz, 20oz, or a Pitcher
Crabby's Beer
Bottles & Cans
Budweiser
Bud Light
Coors Light
Michelob Ultra
Miller Lite
Corona
Corona Light
Dos Equis
Heineken
Stella Artois
Twisted Tea
Reef Donkey 16oz can
Yuengling Raging Eagle Mango
Angry Orchard Cider
High Noon flavors - 12oz can
White Claw flavors - 12oz can
Drafts
Bud Light
Michelob Ultra
Crabby's IPA
Shock Top
Corona Premier
Cigar City Jai Alai IPA
Yuengling
Dos Equis
Landshark Lager
Beach Hippie IPA
Ponce Inlet
Seasonal/Rotating Tap
Wines
House Wines by Flip Flop
Chardonnay
Merlot
Cabernet Sauvignon
Pinot Grigio
J. Lohr
Premium Wines by J. Lohr Vineyards:
Pinot Noir
Cabernet Sauvignon
Chardonnay
Sauvignon Blanc
Crabby's Specialties
Steak & Eggs*
$28.99
12oz New York Strip with two cage free eggs, with side of home fries
Cafe Bustelo iced coffee with French vanilla cream
Coconut Cappuccino
Coconut rum and amaretto blended with frozen coffee
Frozen Irish Coffee
Jameson, Baileys and creme de menthe blended into a delicious frozen drink
Dirty Banana Coffee
Plantation rum, Kahlua and banana cream mixed with frozen coffee
All-American Bloody Mary
Tito's Handmade Vodka and our famous Bloody Mary mix, served with traditional garnishes and a slice of thick cut applewood bacon
Breakfast Mule
Orange vodka with Natalie's Orange Juice, muddled oranges, and ginger beer
Banana Bread Colada
Gasparilla Banana Bread Rum with Kahlua and house made pina colada mix
Orange Cursh
Natalie's Orange Juice paired with orange vodka, triple sec, and a splash of lemon-lime soda
Dan the ManMosa
Natalie's Orange Juice and prosecco, with vodka, triple sec, and Red Bull
Peach Bellini
Prosecco with peach puree and peach schnapps
Purple Coconut
Muddled blackberries with vanilla vodka, coconut cream, and pineapple juice
Consuming raw or undercooked oysters, meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses, especially if you have a medical condition.
Mainland
Chicken Fingers
$5.99
Grilled Chicken
$5.99
Mac and Cheese
$5.99
Hamburger or Cheeseburger
$5.99
Alfredo Pasta
$5.99
Seafood
Grilled Fish
$6.99
Fried Shrimp
$6.99
Fish Fingers
$6.99
Monthly Specials
Try a Sun Cruiser for $1!
Real Iced Tea. Real Vodka. Scan the QR Code on the menu in store and get $5 cash back via PayPal or Venmo when you purchase a Sun Cruiser Iced Tea & Vodka!
Alaskan Crab Roll
$16.99
chilled Alaskan snow crab meat gently folded with Hellman's mayo, seasoned with a perfect amount of Old Bay and served on a toasted New England style roll served with your choice of one side.
Coconut Lobster Bites
$16.99
Caribbean lobster chunks lightly breaded in our coconut & panko breading and served with tropical pina colada sauce.
Shrimp Po' Boy
$16.99
A traditional dressed Po' Boy with hand-breaded red shrimp, our remoulade sauce on a toasted amoroso roll.
Beachside Nachos
$16.99
crispy tortilla chips topped with blackened wild red shrimp, savory black beans, cherry peppers, pico de gallo, seasoned queso blanco, and fresh cilantro.
Firecracker Chicken Pasta
$18.99
Linguine pasta with a spicy chipotle pepper sauce, chopped scallions, tomato, and topped with a filet of sliced blackened chicken.
Blueberry Cheesecake
Two award winning desserts in one! Mike's Pies very own blueberry pie and his famous NY cheesecake come together in his gluten free graham cracker crust.