What's wrong with this menu?
Comfort Diner
1281 Arthur Kill Rd
Staten Island, NY 10312
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Salads
A Large Caesar Salad
romaine, shredded parmesan & homemade garlic croutons tossed with a delicious caesar dressing.
- $7.95
- Add Grilled Chicken Or Portobello Mushroom For (bucks) $3.00
- Grilled Shrimp For (bucks) $6.00
Pear And Gorgonzola Salad
mixed greens, pears, gorgonzola, pistachios, grapes & dried cranberries tossed with raspberry vinaigrette.
- $9.95
- Add Grilled Chicken For (bucks) $3.00
- Grilled Shrimp For (bucks) $6.00
Comfort Diner Signature Salad
oven roasted tomatoes, artichoke hearts, chickpeas
and warm goat cheese atop balsamic vinaigrette tossed greens.
- $9.95
- Add Grilled Chicken Or Portobello Mushroom For (bucks) $3.00
- Grilled Shrimp For (bucks) $6.00
Warm Taco Salad
$10.95
ground beef, shredded cheddar, salsa, sour cream & tortilla chips atop shredded lettuce.
also available with seasoned shredded chicken breast!
Classic Chefs Salad
$11.95
roasted turkey breast, country ham, swiss and cheddar cheeses, hard boiled egg,
cucumbers and cherry tomatoes atop romaine lettuce and served with blue cheese dressing
Pistachio Chicken Salad (low Carb)
$11.95
pistachio crusted chicken breast, asparagus & cherry tomatoes tossed w/romaine & avocado lime dressing.
Sandwiches
All Of Our Sandwiches Are Served With
Homemade Coleslaw, A Great Pickle
And Your Choice Of French Fries, Rice Or
Steamed Broccoli. For A Buck You Can Switch To
Sweet Potato Fries, Roast Garlic Or Mock Mashed Potatoes, Baked Potato Or Todays Veggie. Turn Any Sandwich Into A Wrap Add A Buck
Grilled Cheese
no designer cheeses here - just good old-fashioned grilled american cheese
- $5.95
- With Tomato Or With Bacon Add $1.00
Blt
$6.95
thick cut bacon, ripe tomato, lettuce
and mayo on toasted whole grain bread
Mediterranean Melt
$7.95
goat cheese, oven-roasted tomatoes
and pesto - grilled on rosemary bread.
Classic Tuna Melt
$7.95
solid white tuna salad, tomato & melted cheese
served on a toasted english muffin
Grilled Chicken Club
$8.95
a triple-decker with grilled chicken,
bacon, lettuce, ripe tomato & mayo.
Retro Turkey Sandwich
$8.95
remember this one from the 80s?
roasted turkey breast, muenster cheese, avocado,
sprouts, tomato & honey mustard on whole grain
Pulled Bbq Pork
$8.95
slow cooked bbq pork on a soft bun w/cheddar
& caramelized onions. melt in your mouth delicious.
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
$8.95
crispy chicken breast tossed with spicy buffalo wing
sauce served with lettuce, tomato, shredded carrot
and bleu cheese dressing on a hero roll.
Grilled Reuben
$9.95
corned beef piled high with sauerkraut,
swiss & thousand island dressing on grilled rye
Southwestern Chicken Wrap
$9.95
grilled chicken, avocado, pepper jack cheese,
lettuce, tomato & chipotle mayo in a black bean wrap
Philly Cheese Steak
$10.95
thinly sliced top round, loads of sauteed
mushrooms, onions and cheese whiz,
provolone or american cheese on a hero roll.
Comfort Burger (beef, Buffalo, Turkey Or Veggie)
$7.99
a delicious half-pound broiled to
perfection and placed on a comfortable bun.
make it a cheeseburger...on us.
Imagination Burger
top your burger: mushrooms, caramelized onions,
avocado, or vegetarian chili.
add one cheese on us.
- $9.95
- $1.00
Maine Crab Burger
$13.95
a great crab cake served on a big bun with sweet
potato fries, zippy tartar sauce and creamy coleslaw
Bacon Each Additional Cheese And
Small Plates
A Nice Bowl Of Soup
- $1.95
- $3.95
Grandmas Chicken Soup
loaded with chicken, carrots,
celery and noodles. yum!
- $1.95
- $3.95
A Nice Green Salad
$3.95
with tomato, cucumber and red onion.our dressing choices: house vinaigrette, bleu
cheese, thousand island, ranch,
avocado lime or citrus vinaigrette.
Caesar Salad
$4.95
hearts of romaine, shredded parmesan and homemade garlic croutons tossed with a delicious caesar dressing
A Cup Of Vegetarian Chili
$4.95
with shredded cheddar cheese, sour cream, house made salsa and crisp tortilla chips.
Wild Mushroom Potato Pancakes
$6.95
with our homemade chunky
applesauce and sour cream.
Mozzarella Wedges
$6.95
frozen? fuggeddaboudit! made right here,
battered, fried and served with marinara sauce.
Potato Skins
baked and stuffed with bacon and cheddar then topped with a dollop of sour cream.
- $6.95
- Add Our Vegetarian Chili For $2.00
Mac & Cheese Bites
$7.95
addictively delicious.
Buffalo Chicken Wings
$7.95
spicy wings with bleu cheese dressing,
Grilled Chicken Skewers
$7.95
marinated chicken breast grilled and
served with honey mustard or barbecue dipping sauce and mixed greens.
Comfort Quesadilla
loaded with pepper jack cheese
and black beans. topped with fresh
salsa and sour cream.
- $7.95
- Add Avocado For $2.00
- Add Chicken For $3.00
- Add Grilled Shrimp For $6.00
Sliders (mini Burgers)
four delicious mini burgers with
lettuce and tomato on brioche rolls. served with
french fries or sweet potato fries
- $10.95
- Make It A Double Order For $18.95
Large Plates
Add Soup Or Salad Plus Coffee And Dessert For 3.95
A Big Bowl Of Vegetarian Chili
$9.95
a hearty, healthy helping of our chili topped w/cheddar, sour cream, fresh salsa & crisp corn tortilla chips.
Chili Mac
$9.95
we top half an order of our mac & cheese w/half an order of our vegetarian chili its a great combo!
make it chili mac con carne we add seasoned ground beef for two bucks more
Angel Hair Pasta
with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and basil in a white wine sauce.
- $10.95
- Add Grilled Chicken Or Portobello Mushroom For (bucks) $3.00
- Add Grilled Shrimp For (bucks) $6.00
Salmon Croquettes
$11.95
we use fresh salmon, celery and onions for our version of this comfort food staple.
we pan fry two generous patties and serve them with remoulade sauce, steamed broccoli and jasmine rice.
Grilled Soft Shell Chicken Tacos
two soft tortillas filled with chicken, chopped lettuce, fresh salsa and shredded
pepper jack cheese. served with black beans, spanish rice and guacamole.
- $12.95
- Also Available As Steak Tacos $16.95
Pecan Crusted Catfish
$13.95
drizzled w/garlic lime butter and served with mashed sweet potatoes and collard greens.
Chicken Fried Chicken
$13.95
chicken breast dusted in seasoned flour and pan fried until nice n crispy.
with a heap of roast garlic mashed potatoes, lumpy cream gravy and collard greens
Bbq Pulled Pork Platter
$13.95
with bourbon bbq sauce, baked beans, grilled corn on the cob and cole slaw.
a taste of the south up here in the north.
Parmesan Crusted Chicken
$14.95
parmesan crusted chicken breast, pan seared
and served with sage butter sauce, roasted new potatoes and todays vegetable.
Pork Chop & Applesauce
$14.95
double thick center cut chop with our homemade chunky applesauce,
roast garlic mashed potatoes and todays vegetable.
Brinleys Lemon Chicken
$14.95
seared chicken breast served with sauteed mushrooms, a lovely
light lemon pan sauce, jasmine rice and the vegetable of the day
Oven Crisped Fish And Chips
$14.95
if you love fish and chips but are afraid of the fryer, this version if for you. we top scrod fillet with
seasoned bread crumbs and cut idaho potatoes into nice thick wedges. then we bake both until they
get nice and crispy and serve it to you with home made tartar sauce, coleslaw and malt vinegar.
Herb Crusted Salmon (low Carb)
$15.95
pan seared and served with steamed broccoli and mock mashed potatoes.
Hooray For Steak
$18.95
a succulent 14 oz. t-bone steak served with a nice baked potato and todays vegetable.
Dinner Classics
Add Soup Or Salad Plus Coffee And Dessert For $3.95
Macaroni And Cheese
$9.95
macaroni & a yummy blend of cheese baked with a crunchy golden top.
Comforting Chicken Pot Pie
$13.95
savory chunks of chicken, carrots, celery, potatoes and peas in a
velvety cream sauce baked with a flaky crust. it doesnt get better than this!
Broiled Fillet Of Sole
$13.95
flaky and delicately delicious. served with jasmine rice & steamed broccoli.
order it stuffed with spinach and feta add two bucks.
Thanksgiving Every Day
$14.95
talk about comfort food! roasted turkey breast, stuffing, mashed potatoes w/gravy, homemade cranberry sauce and fresh veggies. you will thank us
Moms Meatloaf (on Her Best Day)
$14.95
with caramelized onion & mushroom gravy, roast garlic mashed potatoes and todays vegetable.
sorry, mom, but we dont ever remember yours tasting this good.
Honey Dipt Southern Fried Chicken
$14.95
with mac & cheese and collard greens
Yankee Pot Roast
$14.95
slowly simmered with the traditional carrots, celery, onions
and new potatoes. so tender you can cut it with a fork
Sirloin Steak Tips W/mushroom Onion Gravy
$16.95
served over buttered egg noodles and with steamed broccoli