What's wrong with this menu?
Carl's Cafe
222 Elmira Rd
Ithaca, NY 14850
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Menu
Specialty Pizza
White Garlic Pizza
Create your own white pizza! Start with house-made white garlic sauce, referred toppings covered with mozzarella cheese
- 12" Medium $12.49
- 16" Large $18.49
- 18" X25" Sheet $29.99
New York Style Pizza
A thin and crispy crust with our signature red sauce, a little extra oregano and mozzarella cheese, add your favorite toppings or keep it a "New York classic" just cheese
- 12" Medium $12.49
- 16" Large $18.49
- 18" X25" Sheet $29.99
Pasta
Cavatappi. Build your own pasta. Try any sauce with your favorite toppings. Full portion 1 lb
Homestyle Red Sauce Pasta
Thick, savory and sweet. Made with fresh California tomatoes
- 1/2 Portion $5.99
- Full Portion $9.99
House-Made White Garlic Sauce Pasta
Smooth and buttery, made with fresh garlic and our house spice blend
- 1/2 Portion $5.99
- Full Portion $9.99
Wings and Things
Choose a sauce: Mild House-Made Buffalo Sauce, Medium House-Made Buffalo Sauce, Hot House-Made Buffalo Sauce, BBQ Sauce, Garlic Parmesan Sauce, Country Sweet Sauce, Carolina Gold Sauce, Honey Mustard Sauce, Marinara Sauce, House-Made Blue Cheese Sauce, Ranch Sauce. Choose a dipping sauce: House-Made Blue Cheese Sauce, Ranch Sauce
10 Boneless Wings
$10.99
All white meat. Served with our house-made blue cheese or ranch and celery
10 Traditional Wings
$11.49
Fresh, jumbo, deep-fried. Served with our house-made blue cheese or ranch and celery