What's wrong with this menu?
Captain Tony's Pizza
1405 E 9th St
Cleveland, OH 44114
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Salads
Garden Salad With Dressing
- Regular $2.55
- Large $5.95
Buffalo Chicken
- Regular $4.99
- Large $7.99
Chicken Salad
Steak Salad
Antipasto Salad
Garlic Bread (4)
freshly baked bread topped with our own chopped garlic
an herbs seasoning butter.
- $1.95
- With Delicious Mozzarella Cheese $2.35
- With Mozzarella Cheese & Slice Of Tomato $2.55
Hot Garlic Bread Stix
$4.95
strips of baked dough smothered in cheese & garlic and
seasoned for a hot taste. spaghetti sauce on the side.
Cheese Bread Stix
$4.95
strips of baked dough smothered in butter & cheese
Sin Stix
$4.95
strips of fresh baked dough covered with butter, smothered
with cinnamon, sugar and loaded with creamy white
icing.
Brownie Chunks
$4.45
10 chewy fudge brownie chunks with dipping sauce.
Mozzarella Stix
$5.10Over A Pound Of Cheese Fries
$6.95
smothered with provolone and cheddar cheese
Regular Fries
$1.991/2 Lb. Seasoned Potato Wedges
$2.991/2 Lb. Sweet Potato Fries
$2.99Cheese Potato Wedges
$8.951/2 Lb. Battered Onion Rings
$3.99Dinner Specialities
Spaghetti
$5.50Baked Ziti With Mozzarella
$5.99Stuffed Shells
$6.99Baked Lasagna
$6.99Baked Eggplant Parmesan
$6.99Pulled Pork
$8.99
smoked tender pulled pork, slow cooked. choice of bbq, buffalo or
sweet & sour sauce
Ziti Romano
$6.99
with meat and cheeses
Smoked Bbq Baby Back Ribs
specialities are served with garlic bread
- 1/2 Rack $11.99
- Full Rack $19.99
Deli Style Subs
Free Extras: Fried Green Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Hot Peppers, Lettuce, Tomato, Dressing Cheese Add $0.40
Captain's Supreme
a combination of three meats with lettuce, tomato and dressing
- Half $3.95
- Whole $6.95
Ham Sub
- Half $4.35
- Whole $6.95
Turkey Breast Sub
- Half $4.35
- Whole $6.95
Roast Beef Sub
- Half $4.35
- Whole $6.95
Tuna Sub
- Half $4.35
- Whole $6.95
Meatball Sub
hot, spicy italian meatball with sauce and mozzarela
- Half $4.35
- Whole $6.95
Eggplant Sub
tender, breaded slices of eggplant with sauce and mozzarella
- Half $4.35
- Whole $6.95
Steak Sub
tender shaved ribeye steak on a toasted roll with mozzarella choice of bbq sauce, cajun spices or buffalo sauce
- Half $4.99
- Whole $7.00
Chicken Breast Sub
(baked or breaded)
choice of bbq sauce, cajun spices, buffalo sauce or
tomato sauce with mozzarell
- Half $4.99
- Whole $7.00
Pizza Sub
our special pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese and
your choice of 1 topping
- Whole $6.95
Italian Burger
1/2 pound of choice beef, lettuce, tomato, mayo and
provolone cheese
- Half $4.99
- Whole $7.00
Pulled Pork
smoked tender pulled pork, slow cooked. choice of bbq,
buffalo or sweet & sour sauce
- Half $4.99
- Whole $7.00
Gourmet Pizza Specialties
Pan Or Ny Thin (sm) $9.99 (med) $13.99 (lg) $15.99 (ex Lg)$17.99
;
Deep Dish (sm) N/a (med) $15.99 (lg) $19.99 (ex Lg) N/a
Captain's Classic
pepperoni, italian sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and cheese, no substitutions please
Five Cheese Pizza
mozzarella, cheddar sharp provolone, romano and ricotta cheese, add your own toppings
Pizza Primavera
a low fat vegetarian delight broccoli red and green peppers, mushrooms black olives eggplant and cheese
Pesto
a special blend of green basil sauce loaded with mozzarella cheese
White Clam Pizza
white clam sauce, lots of clams and double cheese
Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
served with tender, shaved rib-eye steak with a blend of mozzarella and provolone cheese
and onions
Hawaiian Delight
pineapple, ham, black olives, mozzarella and cheddar cheese
Spaghetti & Meatball Pizza
this unique pizza has spaghetti sauce, meatballs and mounds of spaghetti, covered in
mozzarella cheese
Chicken Alfredo
buttery blend of creamy cheeses and marinated breaded chicken
Buffalo Or Bbq Chicken Pizza
tender strips of marinated chicken, tangy bbq sauce and cheddar & mozzarella cheeses.
Captain's Feast
our 'classic' plus the addition of cheddar cheese meatballs and black olives
Pulled Pork Pizza
mozzarella cheese & smoked tender pulled pork, slow cooked. choice of bbq, buffalo or sweet & sour sauc
Captain's Mexican Pizza
spicy meat and tomato sauce topped with 3 kind of peppers onions black olives sliced tomatoes, cheddar and mozzarella cheese
Captains Cattleman
pepperoni, sausage, ham, salami and meatballs. a hearty meat lovers delight
Pizza - Crusts
Your Choice
New York Thin Crust
authentic, take a trip to brooklyn without leaving town, made to be folded when you eat it
Garlic Pizza
a white pizza with chopped garlic, oil, grated romano, and mozzarella cheeses, pan or ny thin
Pan Pizza
the original captains recipe direct from italy. our
specially seasoned dough is baked to a thick, golden brown
crust. (sicilian style
- Small (4 Slices) $5.99
- Medium (8 Slices) $9.49
- Large (10 Slices) $10.99
- Ex-large (16 Slices) $12.99
Deep Dish
chicago style, extra mozzarella makes this pizza a cheese lovers delight, generous toppings provided at regular prices
- Medium (6 Slices) $11.49
- Large (8 Slices) $16.99
Party Sheet Pizza
biggest in town, the largest pan or ny style we make the perfect pizza for parties!
- (each) $20.45
Stuffed Pizza
a white pizza with double crust filled with mozzarella and served zesty italian sauce on the side
- Medium (6 Slices) $11.49
- Large (8 Slices) $16.99
Pizza Slices
Ny Super Slice + Double Cheese Or Pepperoni
$2.50
additional toppings 60cents ea. available mon.-sat. 11am-2pm.
all pizzas are available on whole wheat dough upon
request. no extra charge!
Pizza Toppings
Toppings
half toppings are charged half price and put on half of the pizza pepperoni, salami, ham, sweet red peppers, black olives, spinach, garlic, provolone cheese, sausage, anchovies, hot peppers, broccoli, green peppers, broccoli, green olives, mushrooms, sliced tomatoes, swiss cheese, meatballs, clams, green peppers, eggplant, onions, pineapple cheddar cheese, ricotta cheese
- Small $1.05
- Medium $1.45
- Large $1.55
- Ex-large $1.75
Calzones
Calzones
turnover-shaped pizza dough filled with ricotta, romano and mozzarella cheeses filled with sauce on the side. same as pizza filling
- $6.25
- Fillings $0.95
Chicken Tenders
Jumbo Chicken Wings Or New Boneless Wings
$6.30
oven roasted, jumbo wings served 10 to an order.
4 varieties: buffalo style (our house specialty), bbq, cajun, garlic butter
Baked Breaded Chicken Tenders
$6.30
specially breaded chicken tenders served 12 lb. to an order.
4 varieties: buffalo style (our house specialty), bbq, cajun, garlic butter
Browse Nearby
General Info
About Us
The entire family pitched in and helped, including his young son Michael. Grown up and away at college, Michael found that old adage to be true that you just can't beat home cooking, dad's pizza that is. In all of his travels at that time, sampling a variety of pizzas in several states across the country, he was not able to find a pizza that rivaled his own father's. His cousin (also named Michael) also agreed and the family decided to share this great pizza with the world by expanding into a franchise in 1985. From that day on, grateful tastebuds coast to coast in the U.S.A. and also in Europe were able to experience firsthand the crispy, brick oven pizza that Antonio Martella served to his family and to New York for so long.