Captain Frosty’s dairy-bar style building was erected in the late 1950s, and operated as a soft-serve ice cream stand for the next 20 or so years.In 1976, we launched Captain Frosty's, eventually expanding both the menu and the building. While still offering soft-serve ice cream, we also feature an extensive menu of fresh local seafood – all available to enjoy in our casual dining-room, outdoors on a brick terrace, or wrapped to go