What's wrong with this menu?
Buttercup Bake Shop
973 2nd Ave
New York, NY 10022
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Classic desserts baked from scratch every day. Suggested Serving Sizes: 2 layer 7” (5 - 6), 2 layer 9” (10 - 15), 3 layer 7” (6 - 8), 3 layer 9” (15 - 18), 1/2 Sheet Cake (25 - 35). These cakes can accommodate the following frosting flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Mocha, Lemon, Peanut Butter. ½ sheet cakes available inselect flavors - $88. Inscriptions - $3, Standard Border Decoration - $7
Classic Cupcakes
Custom inscriptions available for an additional $0.50
Buttercup Golden
Fluffy vanilla cake with choice of vanilla or chocolate buttercream
- Each $3.00
- Dozen $36.00
Classic Chocolate
Rich chocolate cake with choice of vanilla or chocolate buttercream
- Each $3.00
- Dozen $36.00
Lemon
Light and lemony cake with zesty lemon buttercream
- Each $3.00
- Dozen $36.00
Red Velvet
Buttery cake with a hint of cocoa topped with cream cheese frosting
- Each $3.00
- Dozen $36.00
Mini Cupcakes
- Dozen $18.00
Devil Dog
Rich chocolate cake with whipped meringue frosting & chocolate drizzle
- Each $3.00
- Dozen $36.00
German Chocolate
A light chocolate cake with coconut, caramel, and pecan frosting
- Each $3.00
- Dozen $36.00
Hummingbird
Banana pineapple cake with cream cheese frosting & chopped pecans
- Each $3.00
- Dozen $36.00
Lady Baltimore
Almond cake with whipped meringue frosting, coconut flakes & a maraschino cherry
- Each $3.00
- Dozen $36.00
Specialty Cupcake of the Month
- Each $3.25
Classic Layer Cakes
Buttercup Golden*
- Slice $4.95
- 2 layer 7 inch $32.00
- 2 layer 9 inch $44.00
- 3 layer 9 inch $53.00
Classic Chocolate*
- Slice $4.95
- 2 layer 7 inch $32.00
- 2 layer 9 inch $44.00
- 3 layer 9 inch $53.00
Signature Two Layer Cakes
Sour Cream Spice Cake
- Slice $5.50
- 7 inch $34.00
- 9 inch $45.00
Hummingbird Cake
- Slice $5.50
- 7 inch $34.00
- 9 inch $45.00
Apple Walnut Cake
- Slice $5.50
- 7 inch $34.00
- 9 inch $45.00
Signature Three Layer Cakes
Lemon
- Slice $6.00
- 7 inch $38.00
- 9 inch $55.00
Coconut
- Slice $6.00
- 7 inch $38.00
- 9 inch $55.00
Mochaccino
- Slice $6.00
- 7 inch $38.00
- 9 inch $55.00
Carrot Cake
- Slice $6.00
- 7 inch $38.00
- 9 inch $55.00
Lady Baltimore
- Slice $6.00
- 7 inch $38.00
- 9 inch $55.00
Red Velvet
- Slice $6.00
- 7 inch $38.00
- 9 inch $55.00
German Chocolate
- Slice $6.00
- 7 inch $38.00
- 9 inch $55.00
Peanut Butter & Jelly
- Slice $6.00
- 7 inch $38.00
- 9 inch $55.00
Puddings & Trifles
Buttercup’s Famous Banana Pudding
Creamy vanilla pudding nestled between layers of freshly sliced bananas and Nilla wafers
- Small Cup $5.00
- Large Cup $6.50
- Tub $32.00
Classic Chocolate Trifle
Rich chocolate pudding layered with chocolate cake crumbs and a fresh whipped cream
- Small Cup $5.00
- Large Cup $6.50
- Tub $32.00
Raspberry Lemon Trifle*
Fresh raspberries and gingersnap crumbles wrapped in a blanket of tangy lemon pudding
- Small Cup $5.00
- Large Cup $6.50
- Tub $32.00
Seasonal Pies
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
- Mini Pie $8.00
- 9” Pie $24.00
Gingersnap Lime Pie
- Mini Pie $8.00
- 9” Pie $24.00
Apple Crumb Pie
- Mini Pie $8.00
- 9” Pie $24.00
Chocolate Pudding Pie*
- Mini Pie $8.00
- 9” Pie $24.00
Lemon Meringue Pie*
- Mini Pie $8.00
- 9” Pie $24.00
Pecan Pie*
- Mini Pie $8.00
- 9” Pie $24.00
Pumpkin Pie*
- Mini Pie $8.00
- 9” Pie $24.00
Peach Pandowdy Pie*
- Mini Pie $8.00
- 9” Pie $24.00
Brownies, Bars & Cookies
Brownies
$3.00Walnut Brownies
$3.00Raspberry Fruit Bars*
$3.00Apple Pie Bars*
$3.00Peanut Butter Mud Bars
$3.00Pecan Pie Bars*
$3.00Chocolate Chip Cookie Bars
$3.00Magic Cookie Bars*
$3.00Rice Krispie Treats*
$3.00Oatmeal Chocolate Chip, Sugar, and Chocolate Chip Cookies
- (each) $1.50
Mini Cheesecakes
Caramel Pecan
$6.00Chocolate Almond*
$6.00Chocolate Swirl
$6.00Peanut Butter*
$6.00Red Velvet
$6.00Raspberry Marzipan*
$6.00Pumpkin Spice*
$6.00Coffee & Bundt Cakes
Amaretto Bundt Cake
- Slice $4.50
- 10 inch $32.00
Angel Food Cake (Strawberry Glaze Option)
- Slice $4.50
- 10 inch $32.00
Blueberry Coffee Cake
- Slice $4.50
- 10 inch $32.00
Chocolate Sour Cream Cake
- Slice $4.50
- 10 inch $32.00
Lemon Vanilla Bundt Cake
- Slice $4.50
- 10 inch $32.00
Assorted Breakfast Items
Blueberry Muffins
$2.50Oatmeal Muffins
$2.50Raspberry Cream Cheese Buns*
$2.50Sour Cream Pecan Buns*
$2.50Raspberry Orange Bread
$2.50
*Seasonal/Rotating item, subject to availability and minimum order
Browse Nearby
General Info
Hours
Monday:
8:00am - 9:00pm
Tuesday:
8:00am - 9:00pm
Wednesday:
8:00am - 9:00pm
Thursday:
8:00am - 9:00pm
Friday:
8:00am - 10:00pm
Saturday:
10:00am - 10:00pm
Sunday:
10:00am - 7:00pm
About Us
Jennifer Appel began her professional career as a clinical psychologist. Though geared toward academics, Jennifer also had culinary arts in her blood. She fondly remembers her mother and grandmothers creating a variety of masterpieces in the family's kitchen. At the end of a long workday, Jennifer would come home and unwind by cooking, and by baking special desserts. Before long, her hobby became her passion. Intrigued by the food industry, Jennifer decided to switch careers and go full-time into the bakery business. In July 1996, she opened Magnolia Bakery in New York City's Greenwich Village, where she and her business partner sold cookies, pies, mini-cheesecakes and other delectable treats.