a moist and fruity cake, made with whole wheat flour, fresh apples and walnuts; iced with caramel cream cheese frosting.
2 Layer 9"$40.00
Buttercup Golden Cake
our "not-so-standard" yellow (or vanilla) cake; our most popular recommendation for birthdays.
3 Layer 9"$44.00
2 Layer 9"$36.00
2 Layer 7"$24.00
Carrot Cake
made with fresh carrots and apples, laced with pecans. frosted with cream cheese frosting.
3 Layer 9"$44.00
Chocolate Cake
a rich, chocolatey cake made moist with buttermilk and sour cream.
3 Layer 9"$44.00
2 Layer 9"$36.00
2 Layer 7"$24.00
Coconut Cake
a yellow cake with coconut filling between the layers. frosted with gooey meringue and topped with shredded coconut.
3 Layer 9"$44.00
3 Layer 7"$28.00
German Chocolate Cake
light and sweet, with a coconut pecan filling.
3 Layer 9"$44.00
3 Layer 7"$28.00
Hummingbird Cake
a moist, fruity cake filled with bananas, pineapple and pecans (tastes like your favorite banana bread!). iced with cream cheese frosting.
2 Layer 9"$40.00
Lady Baltimore Cake
an almond-flavored white cake filled with coconut, candied cherries, cookie crumbs and almonds. frosted with meringue and topped with coconut, cookie crumble and cherry halves.
3 Layer 9"$44.00
3 Layer 7"$28.00
Lemon Cake
a very lemony cake made with fresh lemon juice and zest. tastes best topped with lemon butter cream.
3 Layer 9"$44.00
3 Layer 7"$28.00
Red Velvet Cake
yellow cake with a hint of cocoa, dyed a deep beautiful red (tastes like a light chocolate cake). frosted with cream cheese frosting.
3 Layer 9"$44.00
3 Layer 7"$28.00
Sour Cream Spice Cake
a dense cake packed with all your favorite spices, filled with walnuts and raisins. frosted with cream cheese frosting.
2 Layer 9"$40.00
2 Layer 7"$24.00
The Crowd Pleaser Half Sheet Cake
$72.00
(12x18"), available in: -buttercup golden (yellow), chocolate, lemon, red velvet, sour cream spice, coconut, lady baltimore.
Icing Flavors
cakes marked with a can accommodate the following icings:
Vanilla Buttercream
Chocolate Buttercream
Mocha Buttercream
Lemon Buttercream
Peanut Butter Frosting
More Legendary Desserts - Cheesecakes
Caramel Pecan
Individual 2½” Mini$4.50
Chocolate Swirl
Individual 2½” Mini$4.50
Peanut Butter Cup
Individual 2½” Mini$4.50
Raspberry Marzipan
Individual 2½” Mini$4.50
More Legendary Desserts - Assorted Bars And Squares
In August 1999, Jennifer ventured out on her own to open Buttercup Bake Shop in midtown Manhattan. Since its opening, the bakery has experienced outstanding success with its line of old fashioned American desserts and inviting ambiance. Buttercup's classic American desserts continue to be enjoyed by New Yorkers of all kinds, including Martha Stewart, Al Roker, and Senator Hilary Clinton, amongst others. Jennifer has appeared on The Today Show several times, and Buttercup Bake Shop has been featured on MTV, Fox, CNN and more, as well as in the romantic novel A Match Made on Madison by Dee Davis.