What's wrong with this menu?
Buttercup Bake Shop
167 Madison Avenue
New York, NY 10016
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Cupcakes
Apple Pie A-La-Mode
$3.25
Caramelized apple cinnamon streusel cake topped with a ice-cream scoop style vanilla buttercream.
Assorted Sampler
$42.00
A dozen of our specialty flavors. Please list your preferred flavors in the Special Instructions box.
Assorted Sampler (nut-free)
$39.00
A dozen of our traditional flavors. NO NUTS.
Assorted Sampler Minis
$24.00
A dozen of our top flavors.
Assorted Sampler Minis (nut-free)
$18.00
One dozen of our assorted traditional flavors. No Nuts.
Buko Pandan
$3.50
Filipino young coconut and buko pandan flavor, vanilla infused coconut frosting.
ChocChoc
$3.00
Chocolate cupcake with chocolate buttercream frosting. A not too boring classic traditional favorite.
ChocVan
$3.00
Chocolate cupcake with vanilla buttercream frosting. A not too boring classic traditional favorite.
Chunky Monkey
$3.00
A rich dense banana cake mixed with choc chips, topped with choc buttercream and more choc chips. No monkey business here.
Cinnamon French Toast
$3.50
Maple syrup cake with cinnamon buttercream topped with a mini french toast.
Cookies'n'Cream
$3.50
Vanilla cake stuffed with a whole Oreo (yes a whole one) topped with an Oreo crumb buttercream.
Cotton Candy
$3.25
Fun festive sweet cotton candy flavored cupcakes with a light blue and pink frosting.
Dark Choc PB
$3.25
Dark choc cake with Reese's PB cups inside and PB icing. For all you peanut butter freaks out there.
Devil Dog
$3.00
Rich chocolate cupcake with meringue frosting drizzled with choc syrup.
Elvis
$4.00
Soft banana cupcake stuffed with peanut butter sauce, creamy peanut butter frosting, oven dried banana chips and garnished with candied beef bacon.
Espresso Shot
$3.50
Dark choc cake with a nescafe espresso coffee buttercream. Just don't try to eat one and fall asleep. Not happening.
Fun Fetti Birthday Cake
This cupcake is the vanilla cake loaded with sprinkles inside of it.
German Chocolate
$3.50
A light, sweet chocolate cupcake iced with a coconut-pecan topping.
Hummingbird
$3.25
Banana pineapple cake with pecans and cinnamon on the inside, topped with cream cheese and pecans.
LemonRasp Meringue
$3.25
A light lemony cupcake with fresh raspberry jam filling and a whipped torched meringue frosting.
Marble Ganache
$3.25
Vanilla cupcake swirled with a super rich chocolate ganache and vanilla swirled buttercream. A fun twist to traditional.
Pumpkin Spice
$3.50
Thick pumpkin pie batter, cinnamon, nutmeg, hint of ginger, and more secret stuff we can't tell you about. Just trust us.
Red Velvet
$3.00
A delicious red velvet cake with a hint of cocoa, frosted with a true cream cheese frosting. Some south in your mouth.
S'mores
$3.50
Dark choc cake torched meringue, topped with toasted marshmallow, and don't forget the graham cracker crust. Definitely addicting.
Salted Caramel
$3.50
Dulce de Leche cake with Swirls of salted caramel buttercream (sea salt). Sweet and salty, like a typical NY'ker.
Spiced Carrot
$3.50
Carrot cake with apples & walnuts topped with a spiced cream cheese. Definitely a top favorite.
Toffee Crunch
$3.25
Toffee crunchies are scattered throughout this dark chocolate cupcake. Paired with a browned butter buttercream, it's a decadent bite of heaven.
Turtle
$3.50
Caramel filled chocolate cake topped with chocolate buttercream & candied pecans.
Twinkie
$3.00
Vanilla cake with a fluffy meringue interior and topping. Without the 37 anonymous ingredients of a real twinkie. Sheesh.
Ube
$3.50
Imported purple yam paste from the Philippines gives our unique texture and taste to our delicious Ube cupcake and buttercream.
VanChoc
$3.00
Vanilla cake with Chocolate buttercream. A not too boring classic traditional favorite.
VanVan
$3.00
Vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream. A not too boring classic traditional favorite.
Wild Hibiscus
$3.50
Hibiscus cake, hibiscus glaze, meringue topping with zested lemon. Imported hibiscus flower drenched for 24 hours.
Layered Cakes
1/2 Sheet Cake
Serves 25-35 people.
- Hummingbird $94.00
- Chocolate $88.00
- Salted Caramel $92.00
- Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter $92.00
- Color Swirl $100.00
- Vanilla $88.00
- Marble $92.00
- Dark Chocolate $92.00
- Carrot $94.00
- German Chocolate $95.00
Carrot Cake
Carrot cake with apples & walnuts topped with a spiced cream cheese. Definitely a top favorite.
- 7" 2-layer (serves 5-6) $36.00
- 9" 2-layer (serves 10-15) $48.00
- 7" 3-layer (serves 8-10) $42.00
- 9" 3-layer (serves 15-18) $60.00
Chocolate Cake
Chocolate cake. A not too boring classic traditional favorite. Icing Flavor: Chocolate Buttercream, Vanilla Buttercream.
- 7" 2-layer (serves 5-6) $32.00
- 7" 3-layer (serves 8-10) $38.00
- 9" 2-layer (serves 10-15) $45.00
- 9" 3-layer (serves 15-18) $55.00
Coconut Meringue Cake
Our Buttercup golden cake with coconut filling between the layers and meringue frosting on the outside, topped with shredded coconut.
- 7" 2-layer (serves 5-6) $36.00
- 7" 3-layer (serves 8-10) $42.00
- 9" 2-layer (serves 10-15) $48.00
- 9" 3-layer (serves 15-18) $60.00
Color Blast Cake
Fun swirls of color throughout cake. Cake Flavor: Vanilla, Chocolate. Icing Flavor: Chocolate Buttercream, Vanilla Buttercream.
- 7" 2-Layer $32.00
- 7" 3-Layer $35.00
- 9" 2-Layer $44.00
- 9" 3-Layer $55.00
- Add a Color Blast Layer
- $5.00
- Add Another Color Layer
- $5.00
Dolce Salted Caramel Cake
Dulce de Leche cake with Swirls of salted caramel buttercream (sea salt). Sweet and salty, like a typical NY'ker.
- 7" 2-layer (serves 5-6) $36.00
- 7" 3-layer (serves 8-10) $42.00
- 9" 2-layer (serves 10-15) $48.00
- 9" 3-layer (serves 15-18) $60.00
- Add Swirls
- $6.00
German Choc Cake
A light, sweet chocolate cake iced with a coconut-pecan topping.
- 7" 2-layer (serves 5-6) $36.00
- 7" 3-layer (serves 8-10) $42.00
- 9" 2-layer (serves 10-15) $48.00
- 9" 3-layer (serves 15-18) $60.00
Hummingbird Cake
Banana pineapple cake with pecans and cinnamon on the inside, topped with cream cheese and pecans.
- 7" 2-layer (serves 5-6) $36.00
- 7" 3-layer (serves 8-10) $42.00
- 9" 2-layer (serves 10-15) $48.00
- 9" 3-layer (serves 15-18) $60.00
Marble Cake
Vanilla cake swirled with a super rich chocolate ganache and vanilla swirled buttercream. A fun twist to traditional.
- 7" 2-layer (serves 5-6) $36.00
- 7" 3-layer (serves 8-10) $42.00
- 9" 2-layer (serves 10-15) $48.00
- 9" 3-layer (serves 15-18) $60.00
- Add Swirls
- $6.00
Red Velvet Cake
A delicious red velvet cake with a hint of cocoa, frosted with a true cream cheese frosting. Some south in your mouth.
- 7" 2-layer (serves 5-6) $38.00
- 9" 2-layer (serves 10-15) $48.00
Vanilla Cake
Vanilla cake. A not too boring classic traditional favorite. Icing Flavor: Chocolate Buttercream, Vanilla Buttercream.
- 7" 2-layer (serves 5-6) $32.00
- 7" 3-layer (serves 8-10) $38.00
- 9" 2-layer (serves 10-15) $45.00
- 9" 3-layer (serves 15-18) $55.00
Puddings
Banana Pudding
Layers of luscious vanilla pudding with vanilla wafers and bananas.
- 8 oz. (individual serving) $5.00
- 32 oz. (serves 3-4) $16.00
- 64 oz. (serves 6-8) $32.00
- 128 oz. (serves 12-16) $79.00
Caramel Brownie Cookie Dough Pudding
Cookies and Cream pudding layered with our ooey gooey chocolate chip bar and our fudge brownie. Drizzled with housemade caramel.
- 8 oz. (individual serving) $5.00
- 32 oz. (serves 3-4) $16.00
- 64 oz. (serves 6-8) $32.00
- 128 oz. (serves 12-16) $79.00
Lemon Raspberry Pudding
Our tart lemony pudding layered with our housemade raspberry jam and gingersnap cookie crumbs.
- 8 oz. (individual serving) $5.00
- 32 oz. (serves 3-4) $16.00
- 64 oz. (serves 6-8) $32.00
- 128 oz. (serves 12-16) $79.00
Nutella Hazelnut Pudding
Hazelnut flavored pudding layered with pound cake, Nutella and crunchy dried hazelnuts.
- 8 oz. (individual serving) $5.00
- 32 oz. (serves 3-4) $16.00
- 64 oz. (serves 6-8) $32.00
- 128 oz. (serves 12-16) $79.00
Oreo Pudding
Our milky creamy pudding layered with tons of Oreo cookie crumbs.
- 8 oz. (individual serving) $5.00
- 32 oz. (serves 3-4) $16.00
- 64 oz. (serves 6-8) $32.00
- 128 oz. (serves 12-16) $79.00
Strawberry Shortcake Pudding
Our classic vanilla pudding layered with out popular vanilla cake, housemade strawberry jam and syrup.
- 8 oz. (individual serving) $5.00
- 32 oz. (serves 3-4) $16.00
- 64 oz. (serves 6-8) $32.00
- 128 oz. (serves 12-16) $79.00
Tiramisu Pudding
The Buttercup twist on an Italian classic. Espresso flavored pudding layered with dark-roast coffee dipped lady fingers, dusted with a layer of Valhrona Cocoa Powder.
- 8 oz. (individual serving) $5.00
- 32 oz. (serves 3-4) $16.00
- 64 oz. (serves 6-8) $32.00
- 128 oz. (serves 12-16) $79.00
Bars & Squares
Assorted Bar & Cookie Platter
$34.00
One dozen assortment of 6 bars & 6 cookies.
Assorted Bar Platter
$39.00
A dozen of our favorite bars.
Berry Blast Cereal Treat
$3.50
Berry cereal coated with melted marshmallows.
Campfire Bar
$4.00
Toasted graham cracker crust with chocolate ganache, fire roasted marshmallows & fluffy meringue.
Dream Bar
$4.00
Luscious white chocolate swirled with homemade seedless raspberry jam atop a buttery shortbread crust sprinkled with toasted slivered almonds and raw sugar.
Fudge Brownie
$3.00
Decadent fudgy brownie made with the darkest chocolate.
Fudge Brownie
$4.00
Gluten-free. Decadent fudgy brownie made with the darkest chocolate.
gluten-free
Funfetti Rice Krispie Treat
$3.50
Puffed rice cereal coated with melted marshmallows and rainbow sprinkles.
Gooey Cookie Bar
$3.00
An ooey, gooey, buttery cookie bar loaded with chocolate chips.
Gooey Cookie Bar
$4.00
Gluten-free. An ooey, gooey, buttery cookie bar loaded with chocolate chips.
gluten-free
Lemon Squares
$3.50
Tart lemon curd filling atop a buttery shortbread crust.
Magic Bar
$3.50
Graham cracker crust, chocolate chips, walnuts, & shredded coconut magically layered with sweetened milk.
Marbled Rice Krispie Treat
$3.50
Puffed rice cereal & chocolate cereal coated with melted marshmallows.
Oatmeal Fudge
$3.50
House-made fudge layered between a chewy oatmeal crust.
Peanut Butter Cup Bar
$3.50
Crunchy oatmeal crust with a creamy peanut butter filling and dark chocolate ganache.
Peanut Butter Jelly Bar
$4.00
The classic peanut butter and jelly sandwich with a twist. Grape jelly sandwiched between two layers of peanut butter cookie dough. Sprinkled with salty roasted peanuts.
Peanut Butter Mudd Bar
$3.50
Peanut butter chips, chocolate chips, white chocolate chips and a pinch of walnuts in a brittle crust.
Plain Rice Crispy
$3.50
Puffed crisp rice cereal enrobed in melted Vermont butter and Clown marshmallows.
Walnut Brownie
$3.50
Fudge brownie packed with walnuts (inside & out).
Cookies
Assorted Cookie & Bar Platter
$34.00
One dozen assortment of 6 cookies & 6 bars.
Assorted Cookie Platter
$24.00
A dozen of our favorite cookies!
Caramel Chocolate Chunk Cookie
$2.00
Break into one of our gooey Caramel Chocolate Chunk Cookies for the ultimate cookie experience!
Cherry Chocolate Chunk Cookie
$2.00
Cherry flavored cookie dough with chocolate chunks &dried cherries.
Ice Cream Macarons
Ice cream buttercream inside a GIANT macaron! Flavors include Strawberry, Raspberry, Blueberry, Mango, Green Tea and Chocolate.
- Strawberry $4.75
- Raspberry $4.75
- Blueberry $4.75
- Mango $4.75
- Green Tea $4.75
- Chocolate $4.75
Macarons
$2.50
Our famous buttercream inside a perfectly baked macaron. Flavors include Vanilla, Pistachio, Strawberry, Salted Caramel, Lemon, Raspberry, Coconut, Mango, Rose, Cappuccino, Blueberry, Chocolate, Green Tea, Lavender, and Cherry.
Macarons Sampler Dozen
$27.50
A dozen of our top flavors.
Raspberry Jam Thumbprints
$1.50
Buttery shortbread cookies filled with raspberry jam.
Sugar Cookie
$2.00
Chewy sugar cookie, baked just right.
The Bestest Cookie
$2.00
Oatmeal cinnamon cookie loaded with chocolate chips.
Triple Chocolate Cookie
$2.00
Chocolate pudding cookie made with Valrhona cocoa powder & chocolate chunks.
White Chocolate Macadamia
$2.00
Chewy vanilla cookie dough loaded with white chocolate chips and toasted macadamia nuts.
Pies
Apple Crumb Pie
- 6 Inch $10.00
- 9 Inch $24.00
Assorted Mini-Dozen
$36.00
An assortment of our delicious mini pies.
Blueberry Lemon Pie
- 6 Inch $10.00
- 9 Inch $24.00
Coconut Cream Pie
- 6 Inch $10.00
- 9 Inch $24.00
Pecan Pie
- 6 Inch $10.00
- 9 Inch $24.00
Pumpkin Pie
- 6 Inch $10.00
- 9 Inch $24.00
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
- 6 Inch $10.00
- 9 Inch $24.00
Cheesecakes
Cheesecake Variety Pack
$36.00
An assortment of 6 cheesecakes. Please specify your flavor preferences in the Special Instructions box. Flavors include Red Velvet, Dark Chocolate Marble, Raspberry Marzipan, Cherry, Dulce de Leche, Plain, and Peanut Butter.
Bundts & Breakfast
Angel Food Cake (cholesterol-free)
$32.00
A light-tasting, fat free cake, with strawberry fruit glaze available upon request.
Blueberry Coffee
$32.00
Just like your favorite blueberry muffins, with a streusel topping.
Buttermilk Biscuit
$3.25
A classic buttermilk biscuit. Ask about our available options.
Chocolate Sour Cream Cake
$32.00
A rich chocolate-y cake, dusted with Confectioner's sugar.
Cinnamon Scones
$3.25
Cinnamon scones. Ask about our available options.
Lemon Vanilla Bundt
$32.00
A pound cake made with fresh lemon zest, dusted with Confectioner's sugar.
Muffins
$2.75
Muffins come in various flavors, including Banana Nut Crunch, Blueberry, Oatmeal, Raspberry Cream Cheese, Sour Cream Pecan, and Chocolate Chip.
Browse Nearby
General Info
Hours
Monday:
8:00am - 10:00pm
Tuesday:
8:00am - 10:00pm
Wednesday:
8:00am - 10:00pm
Thursday:
8:00am - 10:00pm
Friday:
8:00am - 11:00pm
Saturday:
10:00am - 9:00pm
Sunday:
10:00am - 7:00pm
About Us
We are committed to baking the best gourmet cupcakes and finest sweet goods in the world. With this in mind, we love dazzling New York foodies. Besides putting smiles on our clients with our signature cupcakes, we also bake an amazing array of bars, famous puddings, cookies, and macaroons. Try something unique and fresh; come in and ask for a free sample of any of our newest puddings.