What's wrong with this menu?
Billy's Bakery
184 9th Ave
New York, NY 10011
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Cup Cakes
Traditional Cupcakes
yellow daisy, classic chocolate iced with vanilla butter cream frosting in white and assorted pastels or chocolate butter cream frosting
- Each $3.00
Specialty Cupcakes
daily assortment varies. banana, carrot, coconut, german chocolate, red velvet maple pecan, lemon poppy, almond pistachio, chocolate cherry, dreamsicle, chocolate mint, nutella, chai, gingerbread
- Each $3.00
Holiday Cupcakes
traditional cupcakes decorated with festive sprinkles available for many holidays including: valentine's day, st patrick's day, easter, fourth of july, halloween, thanksgiving and christmas
- Each $3.00
Mini Cupcakes
assorted traditional or red velvet specialty flavors, available by special order
- Dozen $18.00
Layer Cakes
special order cakes are available in 8", 9", 10" and 12" two or three layers
Yellow Daisy Cakes
classic yellow butter cake flavored with pure vanilla extract and iced with vanilla butter cream
- Per Slice $5.00
Classic Chocolate Cake
for the chocolate lover: a deep, moist chocolate cake made with rich, dark cocoa and iced with vanilla or mocha butter cream
- Per Slice $5.00
Banana Cake
reminiscent of banana bread but richer and sweeter, made with fresh bananas and buttermilk and iced with cream cheese frosting
- Per Slice $5.00
Carrot Cake
cinnamon batter with carrots, coconut, pineapple and pecans, iced with cream cheese frosting
- Per Slice $5.00
German Chocolate Cake
sweet butter milk chocolate cake layered with coconut pecan filling
- Per Slice $5.50
Red Velvet Cake
a southern classic, a mild cocoa flavor with a bright red color and iced with whipped vanilla icing can be ordered with cream cheese icing
- Per Slice $5.50
Coconut Cake
yellow daisy cake filled with creamy coconut filling and iced with fluffy, white meringue
- Per Slice $5.50
Pies
Banana Cream
vanilla pudding with fresh bananas, topped with whipped cream
- For 4" $6.00
- For 9" $26.00
Peanut Butter Chocolate
fluffy peanut butter filling in a graham crust, topped with chocolate syrup and peanut butter cups
- For 4" $6.00
- For 9" $26.00
Key Lime, Cherry, Peach, Blueberry, Apple
seasonal, spring/summer
- For 4" $6.00
- For 9" $26.00
Pumpkin, Pecan, Apple Crumb
seasonal, fall/winter
- For 4" $6.00
- For 9" $26.00
Cookies
Drop Cookies
assorted flavors, daily selection may vary
- Each $0.75
- Gift Package $5.00
Cutout Cookies
sugar cookie dough cut info festive shapes and hand iced in vanilla butter cream
- Each $3.00
Cookies Sandwiches
two of our drop cookies filled with vanilla cream, flavors vary
- Each $2.50
Bars & Browines
Chocolate Fudge Browines
deep chocolate batter topped with chocolate chips
- Each $3.25
- Seasonal Bars (each) $3.75
Hello Dollies
graham crackers, chocolate chips, butter scotch, coconut and pecans
- Each $3.25
- Seasonal Bars (each) $3.75
Build Your Own Cakes
inscriptions - inscriptions can be done all layer cakes unless otherwise noted. only cakes that are in vanilla, chocolate, or mocha butter cream can be decorated. prices include inscription and choice of assorted sprinkles. decorations - classic decorations include polka docs, strips, and simple flowers, custom decorations are also available please stop in with an example and we will do our best to accommodate your design
2 Layer
- 8" (serving 6-10) $35.00
- 9" (serving 10-12) $45.00
- 10" (serving 16-20) $65.00
- 12" (serving 30-45) $95.00
3 Layer
- 8" (serving 6-10) $40.00
- 9" (serving 10-12) $55.00
- 10" (serving 16-20) $80.00
- 12" (serving 30-45) $115.00
Cake Decortion
- 8" (serving 6-10) (& up) $7.00
- 9" (serving 10-12) (& up) $10.00
- 10" (serving 16-20) (& up) $12.00
- 12" (serving 30-45) (& up) $15.00
Other Cakes
Pineapple Upside Down Cake
golden brown sugar and sweet pineapple baked the old fashioned way, in a cast iron skillet
- Per Slice $5.00
- Whole $30.00
Famous Chocolate Icebox Cake
fresh dairy whipped cream layered between chocolate wafer cookies
- Per Slice $5.50
- Whole $35.00
Cheesecake
plain, cherry, chocolate, blueberry, caramel pecan. seasonal: key lime, pumpkin
- For 3" $5.50
- For 7" $30.00