What's wrong with this menu?
Benny's
91 Shoemaker St
Forty Fort, PA 18704
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Signature Snacks
Mozzarella Sticks
$6.50
Warm, melty mozzarella cheese tossed in a golden batter, deep fried and served with warm marinara sauce
Onion Rings
$6.50
Whiskey battered onion rings served with Benny's Glaze
Basket O'Fries
$4.00
Our Hand Cut Seasoned French Fries
- Smother it in Gravy
- $1.00
- Loaded with Cheese
- $1.00
- Cheese & Gravy
- $2.00
- Volcano Fries
- $2.00
Chicken Tenders
$8.00
Served with french fries & your choice of dipping sauce
Dill Pickle Fries
$6.50
Crisp pickle sticks fried golden brown & served with a wasabi ranch dressing
Pub Pretzels
$7.50
Delicious soft pretzels served with a warm cheese sauce
Garlic Knots
Freshly baked garlic knots sprinkled with parmesan cheese & served with marinara sauce
- 6 Knots $3.50
- 12 Knots $6.00
- Extra Marinara
- $1.00
Fresh from the Garden
Dressings: Italian, ranch, balsamic vinegar, blue cheese, caesar, honey mustard
House Salad
$6.50
Romaine lettuce, tomato, onion, homemade croutons, topped with pizza cheese & your choice of dressing
- Side House Salad
- $3.50
Caesar Salad
$6.50
Romaine lettuce, grated parmesan, and baked croutons tossed in creamy caesar dressing
- With Chicken
- $4.00
- With Shrimp
- $5.00
- Side Caesar Salad
- $3.50
Benny's Cobb
$11.00
Romaine lettuce topped with grilled chicken, baked croutons, crumbled bacon, fresh tomato, pizza cheese, crumbled blue cheese, and a hard boiled egg with your choice of dressing
Benny's Wing Bite Salad
$10.00
Romaine lettuce mixed with crumbled blue cheese topped with pizza cheese & tomatoes served with blue cheese dressing & baked croutons
Chef Salad
$10.00
A great mixture of our perfectly sliced ham, turkey, swiss cheese, hard boiled eggs, tomatoes & homemade croutons
Handhelds
Chicken Cheese Steak
Seasoned and chopped chicken topped with melted american cheese
- $8.00
- Make it a Buffalo $9.00
Classic Italian
$8.00
Perfectly sliced ham, salami, pepperoni & provolone cheese, topped with lettuce tomato & onion, then drizzled with our homemade italian dressing
Meatball
$8.00
Homemade meatballs covered in a homemade marinara and topped with our signature pizza cheese
Turkey & Swiss
$8.00
Just right sliced turkey & melted swiss cheese served on a rustic rye
Benny's Hot Wing
$8.00
Crispy bites or grilled chicken tossed in your choice of wing sauce with romaine lettuce & blue cheese dressing
Turkey Club Wrap
$8.00
Thinly sliced turkey, crispy bacon, fresh lettuce & tomato, with a thin layer of mayo
Chicken Parmesan
$8.00
Crispy chicken, topped with warm marinara sauce and our signature pizza cheese
Cheese Steak
$8.00
Seasoned and shredded steak topped with melted american cheese
Chicken Caesar
$8.00
Your choice of crispy or grilled seasoned chicken topped with tossed romaine lettuce, our creamy caesar dressing and shaved parmesan cheese
Chicken Bacon Ranch
$8.00
Your choice of crispy or grilled seasoned chicken, bacon, and a blend of cheeses, topped with zesty ranch dressing
Choose Your Style
Choose Your Toppings: Lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, mayo, benny's glaze, jalapeños, mushrooms, fried cajun onion straws, fried onions, sweet peppers, banana peppers
Hoagie, Wrap, Quesadilla
$8.00
Served with chips
- With Hand Cut Fries
- $2.50
- With Onion Rings
- $3.00
- With Pickle Fries
- $3.00
- With Additional Bacon
- $1.00
- With a Small Caesar Salad
- $3.00
- With a Small House Salad
- $3.00
Signature Burgers
2 - 4oz melt away patties served with hand cut fries. Cheese Choices: American, Swiss, Provolone, Pizza Cheese. Choose Your Toppings: Lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, mayo, Benny's glaze, jalapeños, mushrooms, fried cajun onion straws, fried onions, sweet peppers, banana peppers
Robin's Wake and Bacon Burger
$9.50
Fried egg, crispy bacon, American cheese and golden fried onion straws drizzled with Benny's glaze
- Make it a Single Patty
- $7.50
Benny's Cheeseburger
$8.50
Your choice of cheese and mis it up with some of Benny's topping
- Make it a Single Patty
- $7.00
Mac Attack Burger
$10.00
Chipotle mac n' cheese piled onto whiskey battered onion rings & finished with melted American cheese
- Make it a Single Patty
- $8.25
Pete's Burger
$9.00
American and smoked cooper cheese, applewood smoked bacon, drizzled with Benny's hot BBQ sauce and fried cajun onion straws
- Make is a Single Patty
- $7.50
Wing'n it
Sauces: Benny's mild, Benny's hot, Benny's mild parm, Benny's garlic, Benny's garlic parm, Hot garlic, Hot garlic parm, Memphis bbq, Benny's bbq, Benny's hot bbq, Honey bbq, Butter & garlic, Hot honey, Mild honey, Benny's hot bbq honey mustard, Sweet teriyaki, Sesame teriyaki, Pete's sauce (caution hot!), Benny's bacon brown sugar, Boom boom, Benny's caesar, Hot caesar, Honey teriyaki, Benny's honey mustard, Cider glaze, Sweet chili, Volcano style, Benny's bourbon sugar, Benny's sweet cajun, Sriracha ranch, Youshock hot sauce
Benny's Boneless Bites
$7.75Traditional Bone-In Wings
$8.00- Extra Wing Sauce (4 oz)
- $1.00
- Extra Blue Cheese
- $0.75
- Extra Celery
- $0.50
- Make it a Meal and Add Fries
- $2.50
Dry Rubs
Old bay, signature smokehouse, honey garlic, applewood, porketta & jamaican jerk
Benny's Glaze
Our signature take on a homemade bbq sauce
Stuff'd Burgers
2 - 4 oz melt away patties served with hand cut fries. Cheese Choices: American, swiss, provolone & pizza cheese. Choose Your Toppings: Lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, mayo, benny's glaze, jalapeños, mushrooms, fried cajun onion straws, fried onions, sweet peppers, banana peppers
Benny's Signature Stuff'd Burger
$10.50
Savory american cheese, crispy bacon, topped with hand-cut fries, and our signature benny's glaze
Swisshroom Stuff'd Burger
$10.00
Gooey swiss cheese, savory sautéed mushrooms, and pan fried onions
Buffalo Bleu Stuff'd Burger
$10.00
Rich bleu cheese crumbles & our signature tangy mild sauce surrounded by two all beef patties, topped with American cheese
Benny's Poppin Burger
$10.00
Two juicy patty's stuff'd with cream cheese & jalepeños, topped with bacon, american cheese & Benny's glaze
- Substitute Pickle Fries
- $3.00
- Substitute Onion Rings $
- $3.00
- Add Additional Bacon
- $1.00
- Add a Fried Egg
- $1.00
- Add a Small Caesar
- $3.50
- Add a Small House Salad
- $3.50
Pizza
Hand tossed with our homemade signature dough and baked to a perfect golden brown every time
Plain Pizza
- Full Square or Round Tray $11.50
- Half Square (No Half Round) $7.00
Single Slice
$2.50
Square or round
Create Your Own Pizza
Choose from our signature toppings for your perfect: pie, pepperoni, hot sausage, meatballs, bacon, sweet sausage, onion, hot peppers, sweet peppers, green peppers, mushrooms, extra cheese Per topping $2
Specialty Pizza
All pizzas could be made opened faced or double crusted upon request
Hot Wing (Opened Faced or Double Crusted)
Famous pizza cheese blend topped with seasoned and shredded signature wing bites drizzled with your choice benny's wing sauce, and blue cheese dressing (square or round)
- $18.50
- Make it a Half Tray (Square) $11.50
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Benny's famous pizza cheese blend, seasoned chicken bites and crispy bacon bits drizzled with our homestyle ranch sauce (square or round)
- $19.50
- Make it a Half Tray (Square) $11.50
Double Crusted Steak & Cheese
Benny's famous pizza cheese blend mixed with seasoned and shredded steak stuffed inside two layers of our signature dough (square)
- $19.50
- Make it a Half Tray (Square) $11.50
- Open Face $19.50
Double Crusted Broccoli & Cheese
Fresh, crisp broccoli topped with our famous pizza cheese blend (square)
- $16.00
- Make it a Half Tray (Square) $11.00
Open Face White
- Square or Round $14.00
- With Broccoli (Square or Round) $16.00
- Make it a Half Tray (Square) $10.00
- Make it a Half Tray with Broccoli (Square) $11.00
Meatlovers
Sweet sausage, pepperoni, bacon, and meatballs with our famous pizza cheese blend (square or round)
- $19.50
- Make it a Half Tray (Square) $11.50
Tomato Garlic
Chopped garlic and freshly sliced tomato layered on top of our signature pizza dough topped with benny's pizza cheese blend finished with a sprinkle of rosemary & garlic (square or round)
- $17.50
- Make it a Half Tray (Square) $11.00
Pizza-Boli
Thinly sliced Ham, Salami & Pepperoni layered between Benny's melty pizza cheese blend and fresh dough baked until golden brown (Square)
- $19.50
- Make it a Half Tray $11.50
Browse Nearby
General Info
Cuisine
Pizza