What's wrong with this menu?
Anthony's Cafe
2936 Highway Ave
Highland, IN 46322
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Appetizers
Lobster Martini
$16.00
broiled and sliced south african cold water lobster tail placed over a bed of homemade cheddar-chive mashed potatoes served in a martini glass and topped with a delicious lemon garlic butter
Hot Crab And Artichoke
$11.00
succulent fresh real crab meat sauteed with marinated artichoke hearts in a garlic butter cream cheese sauce oven baked with mild cheddar cheese.
Homemade Polenta
$9.00
polenta triangles oven baked with mozzarella cheese and nestled in our homemade marinara sauce with fire roasted red bell peppers.
Caprese
$9.00
sliced fresh mozzarella and ripe tomato topped with shredded fresh basil, toasted pine nuts garnished with grilled mushrooms and fire roasted red bell peppers.
Marinated Olives
$8.00
an assortment of different olives in various marinades.
Fontinella Cheese
$3.00
freshly grated imported fontinella cheese with extra virgin olive oil.
Sauteed Mushrooms
$9.00
our own homemade classic sauteed whole fresh button mushrooms in a delicious garlic basil butter sauce and oven baked with mozzarella cheese and toasted peanuts.
Orange-garlic Shrimp
$12.00
tender gulf shrimp sauteed in a zesty basil garlic butter and accented with a squeeze of fresh florida oranges.
Stuffed Jalapenos
$9.00
fresh spicy jalapeno peppers stuffed with italian sausage, breadcrumbs and special seasonings oven baked and topped with a basil garlic butter sauce.
Antipasto
$9.00
traditional cuts of spicy soppresata, cappicolo ham and pepperoni served with assorted italian cheeses, peppers and olives.
Bruschetta
$6.00
the italian classic of toasted artesian bread rubbed with fresh garlic and topped with fresh tomato, roasted red pepper, fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil.
Soups And Salads
Salad Dressing Choices
All Dressings Are Homemade And Served On The Side.
Creamy Garlic, Buttermilk Bacon Ranch, Honey French, Tomato-basil Vinaigrette, Caesar Vinaigrette, , Balsamic Vinaigrette, Blue Cheese Vinaigrette.
Soups
all soups are homemade.
minestrone (vegetable) and chefs special
- Cup $2.50
- Bowl $4.50
House Salad
fresh romaine lettuce topped with tomatoes, red onions, black olives and croutons.
- Small $3.00
- Large $6.00
Michelle's Salad
fresh romaine lettuce topped with spicy blackened chicken breast strips, grilled mushrooms, corn, roasted red peppers, tomatoes, red onions, black olives and croutons.
- Small $7.00
- Large $11.00
Caprese Salad
fresh romaine lettuce topped with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, roasted red peppers, mushrooms, basil, capers and toasted pinenuts.
- Small $7.00
- Large $11.00
Antipasto Salad
fresh romaine lettuce topped with sliced soppresata, cappicolo, pepperoni and assorted olives, cheeses and peppers.
- Small $7.00
- Large $11.00
Shrimp Salad
fresh romaine lettuce topped with grilled gulf shrimp, grilled mushrooms, corn, roasted red peppers, tomatoes, red onions, black olives and croutons.
- Small $8.00
- Large $13.00
Steak Salad
fresh romaine lettuce topped with grilled filet mignon and mushrooms with tomatoes, red onions, black olives and croutons.
- Small $8.00
- Large $13.00
Panni Sandwiches
All Paninis Are Grilled And Served With Pasta Salad And Pickle.
Half Panini $6.25, Full Panini $12.00
Caprese
sliced tomato and fresh mozzarella seasoned with salt, pepper, fresh basil, roasted red peppers, capers and extra virgin olive oil.
Grilled Vegetable
julienne cut carrots and green zucchini lightly grilled with mushrooms, corn and roasted red peppers with melted mozzarella cheese.
Bluebird
thinly sliced smoked turkey breast topped with sauteed sweet onions and mushrooms in butter with melted gorgonzola blue cheese.
Sicilian Chicken
grilled chicken breast topped with smoked bacon, roasted red peppers and mozzarella cheese.
Blackjack Chicken
spicy marinated chicken breast blackened and topped with sauteed button mushrooms in a jack daniels garlic butter with mozzarella cheese.
Shrimp Wreck
lightly sauteed bay shrimp in a delicious garlic wine butter with fresh tomato and basil with mozzarella cheese.
Tony's Triple Trouble
thin sliced italian roast beef, pepperoni and sauteed italian sausage with onions and green peppers in a delicious marinara sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.
Joey's Brooklyn Style Roast Beef
thin sliced italian roast beef on our buttered garlic bread topped with sauteed onions, green peppers, mushrooms and mozzarella cheese served with a side of au jus.
Beefboli
thin sliced italian roast beef with sauteed onions and green peppers in marinara sauce with mozzarella cheese.
Stromboli
sauteed italian sausage, onions and green peppers in marinara sauce with mozzarella cheese.
Vegetarian Pasta
Marinara
$11.25
homemade tomato sauce w/basil and garlic,
Alfredo
$12.25
homemade parmesan, garlic and basil cream
Grilled Vegetables
$14.25
seasonal grilled fresh veggies placed over pasta
in lemon basil garlic butter,
Quattro Formaggi
$14.25
4 cheese cream sauce (parmesan, fontinella
gorgonzola and cream cheese)
Puttenesca
$14.25
sun dried tomato, olives and capers in tomato
basil sauce. mild or spicy
Casserole
$15.25
sauteed primavera veggies in tomato basil sauce
baked with mozzarella cheese.
Chicken Pasta
Chicken Parmesan
$17.25
bread crumb dusted chicken breasts sauteed and baked with mozzarella and parmesan cheeses placed over a bed of pasta in a tomato-basil sauce.
Chicken Diavola
$14.25
grilled diced chicken breast in a spicy rosemary lemon garlic butter sauce with grilled mushrooms
Chicken Alfredo
$14.25
grilled diced chicken breast in our homemade parmesan and garlic cream sauce
Chicken Porcini
$14.25
grilled diced chicken breast with sauteed button and porcini mushrooms in a marsala wine cream sauce.
Seafood Pasta
Tilapia Chef's Choice
$20.25
sauteed tilapia fish filet in chef's daily creation of sauce, or create your own sauce placed over a bed of buttered pasta.
Palermo
$22.25
sauteed shrimp, fresh crabmeat and chopped sea clams in tomato-basil sauce or cream sauce.
Shrimp Alfredo
$22.25
grilled gulf shrimp over our homemade parmesan and garlic cream sauce.
Lobster Limone
broiled south african cold water lobster tail over a bed of buttered lemon garlic pasta served with melted butter and fresh lemon and lime.
- One Lobster Tail $28.25
- Two Lobster Tails $48.25
Meat Pasta
Bolognese
$14.25
homemade tomato meat sauce slow cooked with beef, pork and sausage.
Roman
$14.25
sauteed italian sausage, onions, green peppers and mushrooms in a tomato-basil sauce.
Grilled Steak Gorgonzola
$26.25
grilled filet mignon cooked to your liking, sliced and placed over pasta in our homemade gorgonzola (blue cheese) cream sauce
Veal Parmesan
$26.25
breadcrumb dusted veal scallopini sauteed and baked with mozzarella and parmesan cheeses placed over a bed of pasta in tomato-basil sauce.
Risotto Entrees
Imported Italian Aborio Rice Cooked To Perfection
Grilled Vegetable
$16.25
assorted seasonal fresh vegetables julienne cut, grilled and placed over a bed of lemon garlic butter risotto.
Grilled Chicken
$17.25
tender marinated grilled chicken breast strips placed over a bed of risotto with sauteed primavera vegetables in a lemon garlic butter sauce.
Scampi Arribiatta
$24.25
sauteed gulf shrimp in a spicy hot jalapeno tomato-basil sauce over a bed of buttered risotto.
Spicy Blackened Steak
$26.25
spicy blackened filet mignon cooked to your liking, sliced and placed over a bed of porcini mushroom risotto garnished with grilled mushrooms.
Citrus Lobster
broiled south african cold water lobster tail placed over a bed citrus (lemon, lime and orange) risotto served with melted butter.
- One Lobster Tail $28.25
- Two Lobster Tails $48.25
Frutti Di Mare (seafood)
Bacalla
$19.25
sauteed north atlantic cod oven baked with sauteed onions, green and black olives and marinara sauce.
Lobster Tail
broiled south african cold water lobster tail cooked to perfection and served with melted butter and lemon and limes.
- One Lobster Tail $28.25
- Two Lobster Tails $48.25
Scampi Capri
$23.25
sauteed gulf shrimp with sundried tomatoes, olives and capers in a tomato basil sauce. mild or spicy.
Scampi Limone
$23.25
sauteed gulf shrimp in a lemon basil garlic butter sauce.
Pollo (chicken)
Chicken Marsala
$16.25
sauteed chicken breasts with sliced mushrooms in a marsala wine cream sauce
Chicken Lemon Dill
$16.25
sauteed chicken breasts in a delightful lemon-dill cream sauce.
Chicken Santucci
$16.25
sauteed chicken breasts in a lemon-basil garlic butter sauce.
Chicken Vesuvio
$16.25
sauteed chicken breasts with roasted potatoes, rosemary, basil and oregano oven baked in a garlic butter wine sauce.
Chicken Cacciatore
$16.25
sauteed chicken breasts with sauteed onions, green peppers, mushrooms and roasted potatoes oven baked in tomato basil sauce.
Carne (veal, Meat And Pork)
Veal Marsala
$26.25
sauteed tender veal scallopini with fresh sliced mushrooms in a velvety smooth marsala wine cream sauce
Veal Gorgonzola
$26.25
sauteed tender veal scaloppini with sun dried tomatoes in a (gorgonzola) blue cheese cream sauce.
Veal Limone
$26.25
sauteed tender veal scaloppini in a light and zesty lemon basil garlic butter sauce
Filet Mignon
lightly marinated beef tenderloin grilled to your liking served over your choice of a bed of porcini mushroom cream sauce, (gorgonzola) blue cheese cream sauce or a balsamic vinegar butter sauce.
- $26.25
- With Shrimp $36.25
- With One Lobster Tail $46.25
Sausage And Peppers
$16.25
an italian classic, fresh italian sausage grilled and baked with sauteed onions and green peppers in our homemade marinara sauce, mama mia!
Desserts
Anthonyi12s Cafi12 Special Blend Coffee Would Compliment Your Dessert
Banana's Foster
$6.25
the tradition lives on. fresh banana's caramelized in butter with banana liqueur, dark rum and brown sugar served over a bed of vanilla bean ice cream and topped with honey roasted peanuts.
Chocolate Lovin Spoon Cake
$6.25
a giant mouthful of chocolate pudding between two layers of dark, moist chocolate-drenched chocolate cake.
Tiramisu
$6.25
an italian tradition, lady fingers brushed with espresso and layered between sweetened mascarpone cheese.
Vanilla Bean Cheesecake
$6.25
a smooth combination of vanilla bean cheesecake layered with custard and whipped cream.
Key Lime Pie
$6.25
authentic florida key limes. tartly refreshing in a granola crust.
Spumoni Ice Cream
$5.25
a great cool down after dinner. swirled pistachio, cherry and chocolate ice creams.
Wild Berry Sorbet
$5.25
mixed wild berries pureed and frozen to a creamy finish.
Vanilla Ice Cream
$4.25
scooped vanilla bean ice cream.
Browse Nearby
General Info
Hours
Monday:
4:00pm - 9:00pm
Tuesday:
4:00pm - 9:00pm
Wednesday:
4:00pm - 9:00pm
Thursday:
4:00pm - 9:00pm
Friday:
4:00pm - 10:00pm
Saturday:
4:00pm - 10:00pm
Sunday:
4:00pm - 9:00pm